My travel toolkit Find me a hotel in ParisFind me a hotel

Mary Cassatt: An American Impressionist in Paris

|
Last updated:
|
Mary Cassatt: An American Impressionist in Paris

By Ziva Kort

The Musée Jacquemart-André hosted a major retrospective exhibition of the artist Mary Cassatt (1844-1926). Cassatt, an American artist born in Pennsylvania, lived in France for more than sixty years and often exhibited alongside the Impressionist painters. This was a wonderful opportunity to take a closer look at her work.

Cassatt settled in Paris in 1874 and exhibited in the Impressionists’ salon exhibitions. The exhibition brought together 50 selected works across different media: oil paintings, pastels, drawings and etchings, accompanied by various documentary sources. Among the works on display were loans from major American museums such as the National Gallery of Art in Washington, the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York, the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, and the Philadelphia Museum of Art, among others. There were also loans from important French institutions such as the Musée d’Orsay and the Petit Palais, as well as from elsewhere in Europe, including a museum in Bilbao. Some of the works on view are rarely exhibited.

The Mary Cassatt Exhibition at the Musée Jacquemart-André

This monographic exhibition is divided into several sections that let visitors rediscover the artist: starting with her early days as a painter in the United States, her inspiring travels across Europe, the development of her own style, the criticism she received at the salons, and her exploration of the modern woman. These are milestones traced through her paintings and backed by documents about her life.

I chose to open with two works on display in the Paris exhibition. The painting “Baby in His Mother’s Arms” captures Mary Cassatt’s gift for portraying infants with unmatched vitality and tenderness. The painting is unfinished: the faces of the mother and baby are nearly complete, while the rest is rendered in quick, broken, energetic outlines. This painting may be connected to another unfinished work from around 1891 featuring the same figures. In the lower left corner is a dedication from Mary Cassatt to Adolphe Borie (1877-1934), an artist and teacher at the Pennsylvania Academy of Fine Arts.

Mary Cassatt, Baby in His Mother's Arms, c. 1891, oil on canvas, Pennsylvania Academy of Fine Arts, Philadelphia
Mary Cassatt, Baby in His Mother’s Arms, c. 1891, oil on canvas, Pennsylvania Academy of Fine Arts, Philadelphia

The work “A Musical Party” is close in subject to paintings from the 17th century. Musical gatherings and concerts were a favorite theme among Caravaggisti painters (followers of Caravaggio) in countries such as Protestant Holland, France and Italy, and they sometimes hinted at a loss of control and sexual freedom. To me, the coloring and the way the female figure is shown in the lower part of the painting recall the work of Dante Gabriel Rossetti (1828-1882), the 19th-century English Pre-Raphaelite painter.

Mary Cassatt, A Musical Party, 1874, oil on canvas, Petit Palais
Mary Cassatt, A Musical Party, 1874, oil on canvas, Petit Palais

Cassatt was born into a wealthy American banking family with French “roots,” spent several years in France as a child, continued her studies at the Pennsylvania Academy of Fine Arts, and eventually settled in Paris for good. In a sense, she lived between two home continents. That cultural duality shows in her distinctive style and in her success at leaving her mark on the male-dominated French art world, moving between these two different worlds.

Edgar Degas, Mary Cassatt, 1879-1884, oil on canvas, National Portrait Gallery, Smithsonian Institution, Washington
Edgar Degas, Mary Cassatt, 1879-1884, oil on canvas, National Portrait Gallery, Smithsonian Institution, Washington

Cassatt’s Original Vision

Like Berthe Morisot, her French contemporary, Mary Cassatt excelled at portraiture. Under the influence of the Impressionist movement and its artists’ interest in everyday life, Cassatt’s favorite subject was her own family members, whom she portrayed in their intimate surroundings. Her modernist sensibility and her unique take on traditional themes such as motherhood made her famous around the world. Visitors to the exhibition get the chance to discover many familiar aspects of French Impressionism and Post-Impressionism alongside new elements that highlight Cassatt’s American identity. We owe Cassatt many portraits, such as “Little Girl in a Blue Armchair” (1878), a painting rejected from the World’s Fair for being seen as too radical, social scenes, “loge” scenes (1877-1878), mothers and children, and outdoor paintings depicting lakeside landscapes such as “Feeding the Ducks” (1895).

Mary Cassatt and Edgar Degas

The 2014 exhibition Degas/Cassatt at the National Gallery of Art in Washington brought together, for the first time, works by Mary Cassatt and Edgar Degas (1834-1917). The exhibition traced forty years of collaboration between the two artists. Cassatt met Degas at the 1877 Salon, and from that moment her name was linked with his in a long-lasting friendship. Kimberly Jones, the curator of the Washington exhibition, wrote: “From the moment she appeared with the group of painters known as the Impressionists, her name was linked to that of Edgar Degas. Cassatt declared that her first encounter with Degas’s art changed her life, while Degas said of her, ‘There is someone who feels as I do.’ The two artists’ particular sensibility, and Cassatt’s extraordinary talent, captivated Degas, and he invited her to exhibit alongside him and his circle.”

An interest in spatial structure was one of the defining traits of early modernist painting in Paris. In Mary Cassatt’s work, closeness and compression are compositional devices that also mark the work of Edgar Degas, for example his use of sharp viewing angles, shifting points of view and cropping tricks. The two artists clearly influenced one another. Mary Cassatt also appears as a subject in several of Degas’s works.

Edgar Degas, Mary Cassatt at the Louvre, 1879-1880, etching, Art Institute of Chicago
Edgar Degas, Mary Cassatt at the Louvre, 1879-1880, etching, Art Institute of Chicago

An Artist Who Challenged Gender Perceptions

Art historian Griselda Pollock (born 1949) wrote in a book that was groundbreaking in its time for the study of gender in art: “We cannot ignore the fact that the field of art-historical practice is structured by relations of power along gender lines. To address the power of women’s art, we must emphasize the heterogeneity of women’s artistic production, alongside its individual results.”

Most of the scenes in Mary Cassatt’s work take place in domestic spaces, but some paintings look at public space: a walk along a path, a ride through the park, an evening at the theater, a boating trip. These are spaces defined by bourgeois life, showing the social rituals that both create and reflect a refined society. In Cassatt’s work, we also find depictions of labor, mainly tasks involving the care of a child.

The Impressionist group appealed to some women artists precisely because its focus on domestic social life felt “appropriate” and offered them central subjects for their work. Looking closely, it’s striking how little of the typical Impressionist iconography appears in works made by women artists. They did not depict the territory their male colleagues portrayed so freely: bars, cafés, backstage areas and other popular spots such as the bar at the Folies Bergère or the Moulin de la Galette.

In her paintings, Mary Cassatt stayed within the familiar, well-known boundaries of bourgeois codes about what was proper, what femininity meant, and so on. Pollock refers to the figure of the “flâneur,” who, as Walter Benjamin (1892-1940) put it, embodies the privilege or freedom to move through the public spaces of the city, observing but never truly connecting, taking in sights through a controlled, composed gaze that is only rarely a gaze of real knowledge.

The “flâneur” is a kind of male figure who operates within the matrix of bourgeois ideology, through which the social spaces of the city were rebuilt. The division into private and public spheres became, as a result, a division along gender lines. The private sphere was the world of the home, women, children and servants; the public sphere defined a world of productive work, political decisions, government, education, law and public service, for men! As Jules Simon (1814-1896), a moderate Republican politician, put it in 1892: “What is man’s calling? To be a good citizen. And woman’s? To be a good woman and a good mother. What is sometimes called the outside world, and the other world reserved for the inside.” Women were defined and confined. Men moved freely between the two spheres, while women were expected, and required, to stay within the domestic space alone.

In a letter from 1903, Cassatt explained the story behind her painting “Little Girl in a Blue Armchair” (1878). The letter was sent to the well-known art dealer Ambroise Vollard (1866-1939), who had bought the painting. “I wanted to write to you last night to tell you about the portrait of the little girl in the blue armchair. I painted it in 1878 or 1879. It is a portrait of the daughter of friends of Monsieur Degas. I painted her in the blue armchair, and he thought the painting was good and advised me on the background. He even worked on the background himself. I sent it to the American section of the exhibition of 1879, but it was rejected, as the painting was considered too innovative, and the panel of judges included three people, one of whom was a pharmacist!” It is known that Degas had a hand in this painting. The cleaning and restoration of the work ahead of the exhibition confirmed it.

Mary Cassatt, Little Girl in a Blue Armchair, 1878, oil on canvas, National Gallery of Art, Washington
Mary Cassatt, Little Girl in a Blue Armchair, 1878, oil on canvas, National Gallery of Art, Washington

As for perspective: the vantage point from which the room is painted is low, making the armchairs look enormous, as if seen from the perspective of a small person surrounded by oversized objects. The sharply rendered background creates a distinct sense of distance from the figure in the foreground.

Women and the Modern Public Space

Mary Cassatt’s love of the opera began in her youth. She attended all kinds of musical performances in Philadelphia, and the opera in Parma, Italy, was a particular pleasure for her. When she began painting opera scenes in Paris, it was a return to a familiar setting where she felt at ease and happy, much as she did at home, in her various country houses, and in gardens and parks. She often painted the same people, especially her sister Lydia, who became the subject of several opera pieces, as well as American relatives who came to visit. Cassatt painted them watching the show and listening to the music, unlike Edgar Degas (1834-1917), who painted the scene on stage or the orchestra in the pit.

In the work “At the Opera” (In the Loge), the woman wears a black suit with a white collar and cuffs, holds a closed fan in her left hand, and looks through opera glasses held in her right hand. Her hat is tied with a ribbon under her chin. She is a woman visiting the opera for an afternoon performance, and as noted, she is looking through her opera glasses at something or someone who is not on stage. When the viewer follows her gaze further, they discover a man in another box, watching her through his own opera glasses.

There is an important element here: a moment captured by the painter, a confrontation between two gazes, and a sense of superiority given to the woman’s gaze. We find that the viewer outside the painting is presented as a kind of mirror image of the man watching from within the picture. Griselda Pollock (born 1949) suggested, on the study of the gaze: more than any other sense, the eye examines, inspects and controls. Similarly, one could say that this is the subject of the painting: the problem of women present in public, exposed to the prying gaze. The viewer of the work becomes an active participant in the game of the man’s penetrating gaze, watching the main female figure from a distance through his opera glasses.

Mary Cassatt, At the Opera (In the Loge), 1878, oil on canvas, Boston Museum of Fine Arts
Mary Cassatt, At the Opera (In the Loge), 1878, oil on canvas, Boston Museum of Fine Arts

In the painting “Two Young Ladies in a Loge,” we see two young women: the brunette Mary Ellison and the blonde daughter of the poet Stéphane Mallarmé (1842-1898), a friend of Mary Cassatt. They sit upright, deeply absorbed in the opera, their contrasting heads framed by the large curls of the ribbons behind them and by the base of the central chandelier, sealed in the upper right corner of the painting. Both young women carry flowers: Mademoiselle Mallarmé holds a small bouquet wrapped in paper, while Miss Ellison has a flower painted on her fan, which she holds wide open, hiding her mouth and chin.

Mary Cassatt, Two Young Ladies in a Loge, 1878-1880, oil on canvas, National Gallery of Art, Washington
Mary Cassatt, Two Young Ladies in a Loge, 1878-1880, oil on canvas, National Gallery of Art, Washington

There is a great difference between these paintings and the work on the same theme in theater by Pierre-Auguste Renoir (1841-1919), (“The First Outing,” 1876, oil on canvas, National Gallery, London). In Renoir’s work, the young woman is shown in profile, exposed to the viewer’s gaze within the auditorium, while she appears unaware of how she is being looked at.

Pierre-Auguste Renoir, The First Outing, 1876, oil on canvas, National Gallery, London
Pierre-Auguste Renoir, The First Outing, 1876, oil on canvas, National Gallery, London

Men and Women in the Domestic Space

Mary Cassatt also explored the domestic space: the balcony, the garden, the bedroom, the bath. The figures appearing in these spaces are mostly women and children, whom she portrays with great grace and in a uniquely moving way, and it is clear they feel at ease in these settings, though a few depictions of a father and his son can also be found. Cassatt painted her brother Alexander (1839-1906) and her nephew during their visit to her home in Paris in a double portrait that conveys both closeness and formality (The Newspaper). Cassatt painted her brother, a Philadelphia businessman, several times.

Mary Cassatt, Portrait of Alexander J. Cassatt and His Son, Robert Kelso Cassatt, 1884, oil on canvas, Philadelphia Museum of Art
Mary Cassatt, Portrait of Alexander J. Cassatt and His Son, Robert Kelso Cassatt, 1884, oil on canvas, Philadelphia Museum of Art

In another painting, “Mother and Child” (The Oval Mirror), Cassatt emphasizes the bond between mother and son against the backdrop of the oval mirror, which in Renaissance religious works symbolized the Virgin Mary but also serves here as a kind of halo surrounding the heads of the figures.

Mary Cassatt, Mother and Child (The Oval Mirror), c. 1899, oil on canvas, Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York
Mary Cassatt, Mother and Child (The Oval Mirror), c. 1899, oil on canvas, Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York

I’ll admit, I’m very fond of Mary Cassatt’s paintings, and this exhibition is a wonderful opportunity to see her work, gathered from various collections across the United States and Europe. This piece draws on Griselda Pollock’s book, on the website of the Musée Jacquemart-André, and on my own work and lectures on the female gaze versus the male gaze, Impressionism and related subjects, drawing on my experience at a museum of art, at universities, and at academic conferences.

Bibliography

Mary Cassatt An American Impressionist in Paris, Exhibition, JACQUEMART-ANDRÉ MUSEUM, https://www.musee-jacquemart-andre.com/en/mary-cassatt

Pollock, G. Vision and Difference: Femininity, Feminism and Histories of Art, Routledge, London and New York c.1988

A Few Words About Ziva Kort

Ziva Kort is a researcher and consultant in art and collections, a lecturer and the director of the historical archive of a museum of art.
She is a research fellow at a university research center. You can reach her by email at Asfan.k@gmail.com or by phone at 052-3407209.
Visit her website at https://zivakoort.com/

Related reading