Édouard Manet and Berthe Morisot: The Passion in Art

|
Last updated:
|
Édouard Manet and Berthe Morisot: The Passion in Art
Main menu
לקריאת הדף בעבריתThis page is also available in Hebrew

Out of the high, classical and conventional society of 19th-century France grew two great painters, each with a distinct approach, sensibility and style: Édouard Manet (1832-1883) and Berthe Morisot (1841-1895). From the moment they met at the Louvre in 1868, they stayed in touch for the rest of their lives. At first the bond was close and frequent, and later it loosened and changed in nature, but the two always remained close at heart.

For fifteen years, starting with that meeting, Édouard and Berthe saw each other regularly and built a singular relationship, one that mixed attraction, friendship and rivalry in equal measure. But more than anything, the two were united by the passion with which they devoted themselves to their life’s calling, painting, against every obstacle in their path. Their struggles were both different and alike, and so were their fates.

In French, the word for painter has no feminine form. Saying “I am a painter” (as a woman) was the challenge Berthe Morisot faced, a young woman of good family from a well-established bourgeois household, in the mid-19th century. In those days, a young woman of the upper class was meant to marry, bear children, run a fine household, and paint, if she wished, only as a minor pursuit, strictly as an amateur.

Berthe became the first woman painter in the Impressionist group, alongside Claude Monet (1840-1926), Edgar Degas and Pierre-Auguste Renoir, who saw her as their equal in every way. Her fellow painters, including Édouard, recognized her talent and learned from her, just as she learned from them. Art critics, however, treated her with contempt and saw her as a “domestic painter,” a woman who painted only feminine subjects, a passing amusement that would soon grow tiresome and fade.

Édouard Manet, for his part, endured criticism, mockery and insults throughout his scandal-ridden life, because he dared to reinvent painting, turn his back on the rules of the Academy, and move toward realistic directions that were not understood in his time and that critics called “crude and vulgar.”

Édouard Manet cannot tell the difference between a person’s face and a pair of slippers.

Édouard Manet does not distinguish between a painter and a house painter.

Whole families would come to exhibitions just to stop in front of his paintings and laugh. Today, paintings by Manet and Morisot sell for millions of dollars…

Like Berthe, Édouard also came from a family of the upper bourgeoisie, and the two were bound to meet. Manet’s father was a senior government official, and his mother received in her salon everyone who mattered in those days. Berthe’s father was also a senior government official, and her mother likewise hosted gatherings in their salon, entertaining that same social circle.

For fifteen years, Berthe and Édouard maintained a bond that remained largely mysterious. In the end, Berthe married Édouard’s brother. Was there, between Berthe and Édouard, beyond brotherhood and rivalry, also a secret, passionate love? There is no way to know. And in any case, one can only assume their love was purely platonic.

The relationship between Édouard Manet and Berthe Morisot

A meeting, almost by chance

Berthe’s and Édouard’s paths crossed on a winter day in 1868, in front of a painting by Peter Paul Rubens in the Marie de’ Medici gallery at the Louvre Museum, when their mutual friend, the painter Henri Fantin-Latour, introduced them. Berthe Morisot and her beloved sister Edma were hard at work copying Rubens’s paintings. Copying the masters was a required step for any art student of that era.

The two sisters’ parents had enrolled them in painting classes. In 1868, Berthe, together with her sister, was a young and unknown student in those classes, while Édouard Manet, a decade her senior, was already a well-known painter. Five years earlier, he had caused a scandal with “Olympia” and “Le Déjeuner sur l’herbe”.

The writer and art critic Théophile Gautier, who had supported Manet in his early steps, recoiled from the radical turn he had taken, one that trampled over respectable tradition. “Monsieur Manet has the honor of being a danger,” he said. And Manet certainly drew fire.

Édouard Manet, Olympia, 1863, Musée d'Orsay. Image source: Wikipedia
Édouard Manet, Olympia, 1863, Musée d’Orsay. Image source: Wikipedia
Édouard Manet, Le Déjeuner sur l'herbe, 1863, Musée d'Orsay. Image source: Wikipedia
Édouard Manet, Le Déjeuner sur l’herbe, 1863, Musée d’Orsay. Image source: Wikipedia

The young Berthe Morisot, who dreamed of becoming a painter, was drawn to the experienced, scandalous painter with his overflowing self-confidence. Berthe Morisot kept up an extensive correspondence with her family and friends, and her letters are a rich source of information.

She recorded their first meeting in detail, with gentle humor and real skill. The smile of the charming dandy, his blond beard carefully trimmed, met the smile of the shy student, who had been busy, before he arrived, copying the voluptuous flesh of the three sensuous women in Rubens’s painting “The Disembarkation at Marseilles” (from the Marie de’ Medici cycle).

The modest young woman listened, flustered and distracted, to the advice of the painter whose reputation as a ladies’ man preceded him. What does he think of me, she wondered. That I’m naive and foolish, or maybe charming, like all the women who flock around him? “A woman painter, how rare. We should meet again,” the painter concluded, and strode off with his quick, energetic step.

In a famous letter he wrote to his friend the painter Fantin-Latour, Édouard expresses a condescending attitude toward the women he had just met:

The Morisot sisters are charming. It’s a real shame they aren’t men. Still, they could serve the cause of painting by marrying Academy members and sowing chaos among that camp of old fossils.

In the months after the meeting at the Louvre, according to Berthe’s own account, Édouard regularly attended the dinners her mother hosted every Tuesday, at their home on Rue Franklin, in the 16th arrondissement. Berthe and her family were invited to dinner every Thursday at the Manet family’s home on Rue de Saint-Pétersbourg, in the 8th arrondissement.

Intellectuals and artists, including Émile Zola, Henri Fantin-Latour, Edgar Degas, Pierre Puvis de Chavannes and Alfred Stevens, argued passionately there about the great questions of the day. After dinner, Édouard’s wife, Suzanne, would sit at the piano and play with great skill, to the delight of the guests.

Suzanne, a plump, gentle and calm Dutchwoman who looked as if she had stepped out of a Rubens painting, first came to the Manet household as a piano teacher for Édouard and his brother Eugène. Suzanne gave birth to a son, Léon, whose biological parentage remains a mystery. Was he Édouard’s son? His father’s son? In any case, when the boy turned 11, Édouard married Suzanne.

Suzanne adored her husband and treated his many indiscretions with forgiveness and not a trace of jealousy. As for the philandering husband, his loyal wife served as a safe harbor in his turbulent world. Édouard was warm and gentle toward Suzanne’s son Léon and regularly painted him at different stages of his growth. In the famous painting “The Balcony”, the boy’s profile can be made out.

Édouard Manet, The Balcony, 1869, Musée d'Orsay. Image source: Wikipedia
Édouard Manet, The Balcony, 1869, Musée d’Orsay. Image source: Wikipedia

Berthe in Édouard’s studio

“The Balcony”: this was the painting that launched the fruitful collaboration between Édouard and Berthe as painter and model. Berthe Morisot could not yet contribute anything to Édouard Manet in the field of painting itself; she had nothing to teach him yet, but her delicate beauty and charm worked their effect, and he fell in love with her.

They called her a “femme fatale”, a label that flattered the modest young woman a great deal. Édouard needed a new model to embody the modernity of a new era. Berthe fit the role perfectly. Édouard asked her to model for the painting taking shape in his mind: “The Balcony”.

And so, from 1868 to 1874, Édouard painted Berthe in a series of stunning and unique paintings, each one different, with Berthe herself serving as his source of inspiration simply by being who she was. Berthe Morisot reclining on a sofa, Berthe Morisot in pink shoes, Berthe Morisot with a fan, Berthe Morisot in a black muslin dress, Berthe Morisot with a bouquet of violets, Berthe Morisot wearing mourning dress after her father’s death.

Fourteen portraits, more than any other model received from him, Édouard devoted to Berthe, who spent long hours in front of the painter’s gaze and brush. Berthe loved, by her own account, spending time in Édouard’s company, in his studio on Rue de Saint-Pétersbourg, where the smell of paint and tobacco mingled with the perfume of the courtesans who had modeled for Édouard before her.

Berthe recognized immediately the enormous talent of this extraordinary painter, and she knew that one day all of France would also recognize him as a major figure in the history of its art. Édouard, in turn, recognized the potential in Berthe and helped her discover and fulfill it.

Meanwhile, though, Charles Garnier, the architect of the Opéra, described the painting “Repose” as an ugly, barbaric scrawl, and called Berthe Morisot, the model, a sad, gaunt and sickly girl. Berthe couldn’t understand the young architect’s hostility toward her and, to put it mildly, doubted his judgment when it came to painting.

Édouard Manet, Repose, 1870, Museum of Art, Rhode Island School of Design. Image source: Wikipedia
Édouard Manet, Repose, 1870, Museum of Art, Rhode Island School of Design. Image source: Wikipedia

Meeting Édouard was a golden opportunity for Berthe to get to know the master. Did Édouard try to draw Berthe into his net? Did she, his admirer, give in to him? In a letter Édouard wrote to Berthe, he declares his feelings for “the beautiful painter”, telling her how much he misses her, how on every street in Paris he longs to see her shoes with their rose-shaped bows, so familiar to him, how wonderful their time together was in the town of Fécamp in Normandy, and how much he would love to see her again.

No letters from Berthe to Édouard survive. Scholars have expressed surprise at the absence of any letters to Édouard in Berthe’s otherwise extensive correspondence, since she regularly and frequently wrote to her acquaintances, and they have put forward the theory that Berthe took care to destroy any evidence of her romantic relationship with Édouard.

Near the end of her life, Berthe told her friend, the painter Rosalie Riesener, that love letters must be burned. We don’t need physical remains to record the hours we lived through, whether terrible or pleasant, she said. It’s worth noting that Berthe destroyed most of her early paintings because she couldn’t bear their lack of originality.

The young painter was still under her teacher’s influence. In her view, those paintings weren’t fit to be shown to the public. Berthe’s ideal of painting was to capture the fleeting and the momentary and fix it in the best and most distinctive way possible. One might draw a parallel from this artistic principle to her personal life, and conclude that certain letters, too, seemed to her unfit to survive.

Still, it should be said and emphasized that none of this is proven. Did Berthe do away with letters she had written to Édouard? Maybe, maybe not. Did Berthe and Édouard ever have the chance to be alone together? Almost certainly not. Either way, the bond between Édouard and Berthe was deep and meaningful, both personally and artistically. Édouard painted Berthe in fourteen paintings, and no other model, not even Victorine Meurent, the model for “Olympia” and for the seated woman in “Le Déjeuner sur l’herbe”, among other works, ever received so much of his attention.

Many critics see in the way Édouard painted Berthe evidence of his attraction to her, an attraction that found a unique and intense expression in the paintings precisely because, unlike so many of his other models, he never possessed her. On the other hand, Berthe herself, who was not a professional model but a young woman of high social standing, willingly agreed to spend many hours in Édouard’s studio, holding exhausting poses while following his instructions: left leg half tucked under the white dress, the fan held just so, don’t move, now smile, please.

Berthe Morisot with a Bouquet of Violets

The most famous painting, and the one that best captures the unusual love story between the two painters, is “Berthe Morisot with a Bouquet of Violets”. In the language of flowers, the violet has, since the Celts and the Greeks, symbolized innocence, modesty, depth of feeling and secrecy. It’s no surprise, then, that Édouard painted Berthe with a bouquet of violets, almost invisible, tucked into the opening of her neckline. Berthe considered this painting a masterpiece.

Édouard Manet, Berthe Morisot with a Bouquet of Violets, 1872, Musée d'Orsay. Image source: Wikipedia
Édouard Manet, Berthe Morisot with a Bouquet of Violets, 1872, Musée d’Orsay. Image source: Wikipedia

And the story has a sequel. After finishing the painting, Édouard made another small painting showing the bouquet of violets, a closed red fan (the same one that appears in several of her portraits), and a note that read: “To Mademoiselle Morisot, from Édouard Manet.” A gift for a valued model, meant to express thanks, and perhaps also, for a woman he desired, to express feelings of secret love that Édouard was careful never to reveal to those around him.

Édouard Manet, Bouquet of Violets, 1872, private collection
Édouard Manet, Bouquet of Violets, 1872, private collection

Berthe and Édouard occasionally gave each other paintings they had made, as gestures of friendship and esteem. Berthe eventually bought “Berthe Morisot with a Bouquet of Violets” fair and square, after Édouard’s death, which caused her deep grief that lasted until her own death, twelve years later.

1874 in Berthe’s life

1874 was an important year in Berthe Morisot’s life, both personally and in terms of her artistic career. Berthe, thirty-three years old, finally decided to marry her suitor, Eugène Manet, Édouard’s brother. Some say that because she couldn’t fulfill her love for Édouard, she transferred it, for lack of any other choice, to his brother, Eugène.

In a letter to her dear sister Edma, Berthe speaks of false illusions she had clung to for a long time and that had never made her happy. The time had come to take a new, positive step and respond to the courtship of Eugène, a good man who wanted her so much.

Even if Berthe married Eugène out of calculation rather than burning passion, the exchange, assuming that’s what it was, turned out extremely well. Eugène was not a brilliant painter like his brother, but instead of an incorrigible womanizer, Berthe gained a devoted companion who put himself entirely at the service of her art.

Eugène proved to be a fitting husband, and Berthe was happy until 1892, when death took him from her at only 58. In December 1874, Berthe lost her father, and the following January she married Eugène while still in mourning dress. That same year was also the last time Édouard painted her, in “Berthe Morisot with a Fan”, a portrait in which Berthe, unusually, appears in profile, her engagement ring from Eugène on her finger, as if the painter wanted to capture this very moment, the end of an era in their relationship.

Édouard Manet, Berthe Morisot with a Fan, 1874, Palais des Beaux-Arts, Lille. Image source: Wikipedia
Édouard Manet, Berthe Morisot with a Fan, 1874, Palais des Beaux-Arts, Lille. Image source: Wikipedia

From the moment Eugène married the woman he loved, he completely abandoned painting, which had been his hobby, and devoted himself entirely to his wife’s career, an unusual arrangement for the time. The roles were reversed. Eugène supported his wife’s career with devotion, acted as her agent, and freed her from all the practical, administrative and organizational burdens. The couple had money and property, so that financial worries never stood in their way, and the conditions for Berthe’s artistic flourishing were about as good as they could be.

1874 was also the year Berthe turned her back on tradition and showed bold independence, choosing to paint free of any outside influence, first and foremost that of her brother-in-law. In this pivotal year, Berthe stopped showing her paintings at the official Salon of the Académie des Beaux-Arts, after ten years of loyalty, and joined, against Édouard’s advice, her friends who would soon be known as “the Impressionists”.

From that year on, Berthe began to find her own wings. That was the year the group held its first independent exhibition, and Berthe was the only woman to take part. Twenty of Berthe’s paintings hung in the first Impressionist exhibition, one that Édouard Manet flatly refused to join.

Édouard had no faith in the strategy of Camille Pissarro, Claude Monet, Pierre-Auguste Renoir, Edgar Degas and Morisot. He did everything in his power to talk Berthe out of exhibiting there, but she defended her choice firmly, with her husband Eugène’s support.

Establishment, tradition, temperament

Édouard Manet could not deny what his artistic temperament dictated to him, and he never adapted his paintings to the Academy’s rules. Still, in his dealings with the establishment and the critics, Édouard was no rebel. All his life, Édouard pursued honors and recognition and wanted to win favor with the authorities and be close to them.

Édouard’s father had intended his son for a career as a judge, but once he saw his paintings, he understood it was better to let him become an artist. Édouard didn’t follow the official path and didn’t study at the École des Beaux-Arts, but he did join, as a pupil, the studio of Thomas Couture, a painter who was close to the authorities, respected, accepted and esteemed.

Édouard flatly refused to join the Impressionists, who very much wanted to claim him as one of their own and crown him their leader. Manet was about a decade older than the Impressionists and was seen by them as the father of modernism, the one who carried the flag and paved the way for them.

Manet had also been the first to clash with the judges of the official Salon. But the barbs of sarcasm and outrage aimed at him gradually faded, as critics and the public began to understand him. Soon enough he would finally win acceptance from the authorities, the critics, the public. Why, then, take a risk and lose it all, when the success he had pursued his whole life was finally within reach?

Still, behind the scenes, Manet kept supporting the Impressionists: he bought paintings from them, lent money to Monet and Renoir, wrote to journalists praising them and asked for favorable reviews for his friends. Support them now, he wrote, one day you’ll understand.

Manet knew that the Impressionists embodied a new and legitimate ideal, even if he didn’t necessarily share all their aesthetic choices. Over time he was influenced by them just as they were influenced by him, and in some of his paintings one can make out the direct influence of Berthe Morisot.

Berthe Morisot very much wanted recognition during her own lifetime and made real efforts to exhibit and sell her work, but she joined the Impressionists without hesitation. Her era failed to notice her singular talent and filed her away as an amateur domestic painter.

The Impressionists were famously labeled as madmen, presumptuously showing off unfinished paintings dashed off in haste, and Berthe was lumped in with that label. “Among these madmen there’s even a woman,” the critics remarked pointedly. And even once the Impressionists’ talent was recognized, Berthe went on being shortchanged simply for being a woman.

It would take a long time before she stopped being filed away as a mere domestic painter. Berthe never studied at the École des Beaux-Arts, because that official institution, as absurd as it sounds today, was closed to women at the time. Berthe’s and Edma’s parents encouraged their daughters’ painting talent from a young age and enrolled them in studio classes, first with Joseph Guichard and later with Camille Corot, once Berthe showed a wish to paint outdoors, in nature.

Corot trained them to paint landscapes, and in the summer of 1861 their parents even rented a house in the village of Ville-d’Avray near Paris so the girls could paint alongside their teacher. But once they reached marrying age, the pressure on them to marry and start a family grew heavy.

Painting became something secondary in their parents’ eyes, and the real priority was fulfilling the role expected of women, as it was understood then in their social circle. Edma gave in quickly, married a naval officer and went to live with him in Lorient, a port city in Brittany, abandoning painting for good.

Berthe stayed single past the age of thirty and never once considered giving up her dream, her passion, her calling in life. Berthe was not an outright rebel like George Sand, for instance, but she was independent and determined, and she never sacrificed painting, nor did she really follow the bourgeois path laid out for her.

Berthe found a clever way to combine painting, marriage and motherhood. Berthe lived to paint, and when the time came, she married a husband who supported her life’s ideal. When her daughter was born, this new love, too, found its place in that harmonious balance.

Berthe found her own way and was happy, but at the same time she was also tormented. In fits of rage, in her younger years, she destroyed paintings that didn’t seem good enough to her to be seen. For Berthe, painting was a way of life and a way of pursuing an ideal that was entirely her own, and no one could ever take that away from her.

She guarded her independence fiercely, and there is a well-known letter in which she describes the day Édouard came to her home and “fixed” one of her paintings, a portrait of her mother and sister that she was about to send to the Salon. Berthe experienced Édouard’s intervention, as he snatched the brush from her hands and turned the mother’s portrait by Morisot into the mother’s portrait by Manet, all while joking endlessly, as a dramatic humiliation. The painting, which in her eyes had turned into a caricature, was shown at the Salon against her wishes.

Berthe, Julie and Édouard

In 1878, Berthe gave birth to a daughter, Julie, who became another great source of joy in her life. The baby, the girl and the young woman grew up under Berthe’s brush, appearing in more than seventy of her paintings. Her beloved daughter became Berthe’s treasure, as Berthe discovered motherhood at a relatively late age.

Julie’s presence in Berthe’s life opened new doors in her art, which grew more mature and more personal. In Berthe’s final years, the outlines in her paintings grew looser and looser, and her work became more and more original. Up until Berthe’s death from pneumonia at the age of fifty-four, when her daughter was only seventeen, mother and daughter were never apart.

After Berthe’s marriage, her visits to Édouard’s studio stopped, and the two painters saw much less of each other. Still, the artistic and emotional dialogue between them never faded. In the painting “Julie Playing the Violin”, one of Édouard’s portraits of Berthe, painted twenty years earlier, can be seen hanging on the wall.

Berthe Morisot, Julie Playing the Violin, 1893, private collection
Berthe Morisot, Julie Playing the Violin, 1893, private collection

In the summer of 1882, the syphilis Édouard had contracted in his youth in Brazil reached its final stage, and the painter could no longer walk or stand. Édouard rented a summer house in Rueil. Berthe and Eugène also rented a house nearby, in Bougival, and came every day to visit the sick man.

Julie played in the large garden, and Édouard painted her in a blue dress. Édouard looked tenderly at his niece, the daughter of the woman he had loved an impossible love, who had become his sister-in-law. He had already painted Julie as a baby in 1879, and now, in the last summer of his life, as a young girl. And Berthe answered him with a matching painting, reflecting the closeness between the two painters.

Édouard Manet, Julie Manet Sitting on a Watering Can, 1882, private collection
Édouard Manet, Julie Manet Sitting on a Watering Can, 1882, private collection
Berthe Morisot, Playing in the Sand, 1882, private collection
Berthe Morisot, Playing in the Sand, 1882, private collection

Édouard’s death

Gangrene set into Édouard’s leg, and his doctor decided it had to be amputated. Édouard died in April 1883, after a week of unbearable suffering. Berthe and Eugène visited him every day. “Édouard would surely have painted the funeral,” Berthe wrote, describing in a letter the final tribute paid by family and friends, most of them painters and artists, to the man who had meant so much to her.

Berthe looked back with nostalgia on the fifteen years she had spent visiting Édouard’s studio. “I loved that man,” she wrote. “Those hours of cheerful closeness, under his mischievous gaze, when he told me everything going through his mind, our shared laughter.” Berthe took a last look into the small grave where Édouard would rest forever.

After Édouard’s death, Berthe never again took off the black dress, hats and ribbons that he had loved so much. She would never forget their close friendship. Until her own death, twelve years later, Berthe remained faithful to her friend’s memory. She bought his paintings and organized the first retrospective exhibition in his honor.

Berthe Morisot, Self-Portrait, 1885, Musée Marmottan Monet
Berthe Morisot, Self-Portrait, 1885, Musée Marmottan Monet

Mutual influences

Manet influenced the Impressionists, and the Impressionists influenced Manet. Inspired by Monet, Renoir and Morisot, Manet began painting outdoors, in gardens, and lightened his palette. Morisot’s influence on Manet is especially clear in his flower paintings and in his final works, which drew inspiration from the world of Parisian fashion.

The collaboration between the two artists was strong, mutual and fruitful. Berthe was of course influenced by Manet, but also by Corot, by Degas, by Renoir, by Fantin-Latour. Berthe absorbed everything she learned from her teachers and colleagues and used those lessons as a toolkit to arrive at an original art of her own, one whose goal was to capture the fleeting moment under a particular light.

In her final paintings, Berthe went even further than her fellow Impressionists, refining the seemingly unfinished quality of their work, the very quality that had provoked such fierce rejection from their contemporaries.

Berthe’s death

Berthe died in March 1895 of pneumonia, at the age of fifty-four, and was buried in the Manet family plot at the Passy Cemetery, next to her husband Eugène. Buried beside them are Édouard and his wife Suzanne. A year after her death, her Impressionist friends, together with her daughter Julie, organized a retrospective exhibition in her honor, where the full scope of her work could be seen for the first time.

Berthe was deeply important to her fellow artists, both as an artist and as a friend. When Renoir, in Aix-en-Provence, heard the news of Berthe’s death, he rushed to attend her funeral and said: “Life is a desert.” Saying goodbye to Berthe Morisot was hard.

On the eve of her death, Berthe wrote to Julie:

I love you as I am dying; I will love you still after I am dead. You have never given me anything but happiness, never any sorrow. I would have so loved to hold on until your wedding… Our parting is unavoidable. Wipe the tears from your eyes. You are blessed with beauty and wealth, use them well. If Degas founds a museum, tell him to hang a painting by Manet.

International recognition

Berthe Morisot’s paintings are shown in the finest museums in the world. The largest collection, more than eighty works, is held at the Musée Marmottan Monet in the 16th arrondissement of Paris. Most of the works arrived at the museum in 1993 from the estate of the painter’s grandson, Denis Rouart, one of the three sons of her daughter Julie Manet and her husband Ernest Rouart.

Three years later, the museum received the estate of Denis’s brother, Julien Rouart, which included three more paintings and furniture from their grandmother’s salon.

On October 27, 1985, five robbers entered the Musée Marmottan Monet about a quarter of an hour after it opened. Three of them held eight guards and fifty visitors at gunpoint in one of the galleries and forced them to lie on the floor.

Two of the robbers took the paintings they wanted off the walls: five by Monet, two by Renoir, and… one by Berthe Morisot, the one showing a young woman with a fan. The police investigation revealed that a Japanese mobster, who had served five years in a French prison for selling heroin, had used the opportunity to forge ties with local bank robbers.

The international collaboration succeeded, at least at first. The stolen paintings were valued at 15 million dollars. In the home of the mastermind behind the heist, whose artistic taste can hardly be doubted, police found a Musée Marmottan Monet catalog with the stolen paintings circled. Even hardened gangsters treated Berthe Morisot as the equal of Monet and Renoir…

In December 1990, the paintings were found, in fairly good condition, in a villa in Porto-Vecchio, in Corsica. The minor damage they had suffered was repaired, and so, after five years’ absence, Monet, Renoir and Morisot came home.

Berthe Morisot, The Dance Lesson, 1875, Musée Marmottan Monet
Berthe Morisot, The Dance Lesson, 1875, Musée Marmottan Monet

Want to read more about Édouard Manet?

Sources:

Catherine Aventurier, Edouard Manet, Berthe Morisot: Un mystérieux duo, France 5, July 2, 2017 –
Correspondance de Berthe Morisot avec sa famille et ses amis, Quatre chemins, 1950 –

Related reading