The French presidential campaign of 2017 will likely be studied in detail in political science classrooms for years to come. Its surreal script was packed with surprises, drama, and scandal.
François Fillon’s scandals
The results of the Republicans’ primary on November 20 came as a big surprise, pushing François Fillon (born 1954), the former prime minister under Nicolas Sarkozy (born 1955), to the front of the stage. A disappointed Sarkozy, who had also been in the race with high hopes of returning to the Élysée Palace, left politics with his tail between his legs and joined the French hotel group Accor. On the bright side, his annual salary there could reach 62,000 euros. Alain Juppé (born 1945), mayor of Bordeaux and a favorite in the polls, also failed badly in the primary and went back to his city. François Fillon, who during his time as prime minister had been nicknamed “Mr. Nobody” because of how thoroughly President Sarkozy had sidelined him, turned out to be a new man: determined and charismatic. Attacking his rival Sarkozy, he said with heavy sarcasm: “Can anyone imagine General de Gaulle receiving a summons to appear in court!” A pointed jab at his opponent’s tangled legal troubles, which were still far from resolved. “The General, what does he say now?” Sarkozy shot back with undisguised pleasure once the newspaper Le Canard Enchaîné broke the Penelopegate story. Penelope Fillon, François Fillon’s discreet wife, who had always preferred to stay out of the spotlight, was dragged into the headlines against her will. And it got worse. Like her husband, she too was summoned to court, and more than once. Fillon was suspected of paying his wife and two of his children generous salaries, well above the norm, for parliamentary jobs they never actually did. It’s worth noting that hiring family members is allowed, as long as they actually do the work they’re paid for. “If I am indicted, if my honor is damaged, I will withdraw my candidacy,” Fillon declared.

Talk is cheap. Fillon didn’t drop out of the race even after being indicted on March 14 for misusing public funds. On March 28, his wife was indicted too. New scandals kept surfacing around Fillon, with similar claims about money he had pocketed. Most surprising of all, despite all the scandals staining his name, Fillon accepted luxury suits as a gift from his friend, the lawyer Robert Bourgi, without any apparent concern. “So what,” he responded. The French public didn’t take kindly to the fact that Fillon presented himself as a man of pure, spotless integrity and proposed a plan to fix the country that demanded serious belt-tightening, all while serious accusations were piling up against him and he was living comfortably. The campaign pushed the question of politicians’ moral integrity into the center of public debate, a question that would resurface once the new president was elected. There were also complaints that Fillon’s scandals had hijacked the entire campaign. Instead of hearing the candidates’ plans and proposals for the future of France and the lives of its citizens, all anyone talked about was the troubles of an angry candidate who saw himself as the victim of a conspiracy by journalists, judges, and the Élysée Palace. Even though much of his own party called for his resignation, Fillon insisted on staying in the race. “I’m not asking you to love me, I’m asking you to support me,” he told the public. His request went unanswered, and he came in third, failing to make it to the runoff.
The French left had its own surprises too
Another surprise came in the Socialist Party primary on January 29: the big win by Benoît Hamon (born 1967), one of the fiercest critics of President François Hollande (born 1954), his policies and his repeated failures. Hamon beat out the favorite, Manuel Valls (born 1962), Hollande’s former prime minister, who had resigned from his post hoping to win the presidency. Another sorely disappointed candidate, the ambitious and energetic Valls would very much have liked to be standing in the shoes of Emmanuel Macron (born 1977) today, but was left behind.

Yet another surprise came with the rise of Jean-Luc Mélenchon (born 1951), leader of the far left, who ran a successful campaign full of polished speeches and clever use of new technology. Who hasn’t heard about Mélenchon’s hologram, which let him broadcast his campaign rally held in Dijon to seven other cities at once? Mélenchon, often described as charismatic, was disappointed to finish in fourth place and didn’t make it to the runoff. Unlike Fillon, Mélenchon didn’t call on his voters to back Macron to block the far right. He simply announced that he wouldn’t vote for Marine Le Pen (born 1968), who had called on his voters to switch to her side.
So the runoff came down to Marine Le Pen, leader of the “National Front,” and Emmanuel Macron, the favored candidate who had built an independent movement that was neither left nor right, or rather both left and right at once. For the first time, neither of the two major parties, the left-wing Socialists and the right-wing Republicans, made it into the final round: a genuine turning point in French political life.
The last surprise of this surreal campaign was just how aggressive the televised debate between the two finalists turned out to be, a debate that until then had always been conducted with politeness and decorum. The one responsible was Marine Le Pen, who attacked her opponent without restraint, disappointing even a good number of her own party’s members. Emmanuel Macron kept his composure and answered every point with the patience of a teacher addressing a misbehaving student, repeating again and again, in several variations, the line “Madame Le Pen, you’re talking nonsense.” “You are not fit to represent France,” Macron said in closing. The polls were predicting his election to the presidency the following day, Sunday, May 7, 2017. Would the election result turn out to be as surreal as the campaign itself had been?