Michel de Montaigne: The Journey to the Essays

|
Last updated:
|
Michel de Montaigne: The Journey to the Essays
Main menu
לקריאת הדף בעבריתThis page is also available in Hebrew

“Don’t read him as children do, for amusement, nor as the ambitious do, to become learned. No, read him in order to live.”
Gustave Flaubert (1821-1880), letter to Mlle Leroyer de Chantepie (1857)

“That such a man wrote certainly adds to the joy of this earthly life. At any rate, since becoming acquainted with this free and resilient soul, I want to say of him what he himself said of Plutarch: “From the moment I caught a glimpse of him, I felt as though I had grown another leg, or a wing.”
Friedrich Nietzsche (1844-1900), Untimely Meditations

Here I’ll write about what came before the writing of the Essays, and as for you, go read them!

Michel de Montaigne’s Family: From Fish Merchants to Nobles of the Sword

Montaigne’s family background is a fine example of social mobility in the France of his time. Montaigne’s great-great-grandfather on his father’s side, Ramon-Felipe Eyquem, made his fortune trading

Château de Montaigne, photo source Wikipedia
Château de Montaigne, photo source Wikipedia

in salted fish, woad, and wine, and in 1477 he purchased the family estate: Château de Montaigne. His grandfather, Grimond, took another step toward nobility, and after securing the family fortune, gave up trade altogether and entered local politics. Montaigne’s father, Pierre, already saw himself as a nobleman through and through, and turned to a military career. He was one of those French nobles who plundered Italy while eagerly drinking in its culture, and who were deeply influenced by the humanism of the waning Renaissance. After retiring from warfare, Pierre returned to run the family estate, and like his father, became involved in the politics of Bordeaux. He even served as its mayor.

Michel’s mother, Antoinette López de Villeneuve, also came from a prosperous merchant family with considerable influence in local politics. Michel’s maternal grandfather, Pedro López, was a wealthy converso from Zaragoza. Before we get too excited about claiming Montaigne as one of our own (there is also evidence of Jewish converso roots on his father’s side), it should be made clear that Montaigne was not Jewish by religious law (his maternal grandmother was a devout Catholic), and he never saw himself as such (he may not even have suspected he had Jewish roots at all). His attitude toward Jews was open-minded, even somewhat sympathetic, but it never went beyond the boundless curiosity that was so characteristic of him. To him, Jews and their customs were a subject of interest exactly like Protestants, Native Americans, cats, carriages, thumbs, and the sand dunes on his brother’s estate.

Unlike his father, who receives considerable admiration in the Essays, Montaigne mentions his mother only rarely, and their relationship seems to have been strained. Antoinette was an opinionated, active woman who enjoyed her status as mistress of the estate during the long stretches when her husband was off fighting in Italy, and who believed, probably correctly, that she could run the estate far better than her dreamy son. The estate’s transfer into his hands must have caused frequent friction, exactly the kind of thing Michel deeply detested.

Pierre and Antoinette had eight sons and daughters. Michel was the eldest (two older brothers did not survive), and the age gap between the siblings was wide: Michel was 27 when Bertrand, the youngest, was born. The extended family, on both the Eyquem and Villeneuve sides, was large, wealthy, and influential.

Montaigne Learns to Speak Latin Like a Native

Pierre’s campaigns in Italy had a profound effect on his son’s life, both in the education he received and in the attitude he developed toward his father’s experiences and views. Let’s start with the education.

It began with his father’s highly original decision to entrust the infant to the care of a local peasant family. Hiring a wet nurse, or even temporarily placing a baby with her family, was common enough among the upper classes, but that was not the case here. Pierre the humanist believed that, as a future feudal lord, Michel ought to experience the lives of those who would one day be his subjects. One can assume that being separated from his mother at such a young age contributed to the future coolness between them.

We don’t know exactly how long he stayed there. Estimates range from one to three years, but the second stage of his upbringing was the complete opposite of the first. Pierre, whose own Latin was quite limited, wanted to raise Michel as a native Latin speaker. To that end, he hired a private Latin tutor, a former soldier of German origin known as “Doctor Horst,” who did not know a word of French, and everyone in the household was forbidden to speak to Michel, or answer him, in any language other than Latin.

At the time, Latin was far more than just an international language, and comparing it to English today would really not be accurate. Knowledge of Latin opened access to the treasures of classical culture, to a deep understanding of religion, whose role was immense, and to every kind of official literature, from law to science. The quality of a person’s Latin determined the quality of his education, served as a measure of his thinking skills, and was a fairly good predictor of the career opportunities open to him. Montaigne’s unusual upbringing did in fact make him the first native Latin speaker in roughly a thousand years (and probably the last), and it also significantly widened the circle of Latin speakers around him, from his parents and the estate’s workers to the villages tied to the estate.

Pierre’s educational experiment did not end there. The fashionable pedagogical ideas of the time called for gentle, indirect teaching, free of coercion, aiming to awaken the child’s “natural” thirst for knowledge. Unlike other children, young Michel was almost never exposed to corporal punishment or dogmatic schooling. Even his mornings were remarkably gentle: like a cobra being charmed, he was coaxed out of bed by the soft sounds of a flute or a harp. His education presumably contributed a great deal to the independent thinking he displayed as an adult. The unusual framework in which he grew up placed unusual limits on him, while granting him an equally unusual freedom.

College Studies and a Clash with the French Education System

The experiment ended abruptly. At age 6, Michel was sent to the Collège de Guyenne, and had to absorb the shock of moving from country life to city life, and from one-on-one education to a shared classroom. The college was an excellent institution, and Latin was the focus of its curriculum, and although Montaigne’s abilities astonished his teachers and moved him ahead in his studies, his opinion of the college in hindsight was poor: none of it could match the skills he already had, which suffered as a result. Montaigne believed his Latin was worse by the time he finished his studies than it had been when he started.

His years at the college were marked by social upheaval, both in his home city of Bordeaux in particular and in France as a whole. It was the age of the Reformation, and the Lutheran and Calvinist message spread across Europe like wildfire. Religious conversion, and the violent friction that came with it, tore European society apart across every region and class. His home region of Guyenne, for instance, became almost entirely Calvinist, while the region’s capital, Bordeaux, remained a firm stronghold of the Catholic faith. Even Montaigne’s own family was touched by the new faith: his mother and one of his brothers converted to Protestantism.

The religious rift came with political upheaval too. During Montaigne’s years at the Collège de Guyenne, a revolt broke out in Bordeaux over a new salt tax, and the young Michel witnessed the mob lynch the royal commissioner, Tristan de Moneins. The crowd was eventually calmed by the man who would one day become Montaigne’s father-in-law, Geoffroy de La Chassaigne. The Crown sent an expeditionary force to Bordeaux led by the Constable de Montmorency, Anne de Montmorency (1493-1567), who imposed a reign of terror on the region. The city’s privileges were revoked, and were only gradually restored, thanks to the efforts of Michel’s father, Pierre de Montaigne, who served as mayor.

We have no solid information about Montaigne’s youth, but it’s reasonable to assume he received a higher education in law, in Toulouse or Paris, and that around age 24 he began his public career, at the Périgord parliament. After that body was dissolved and merged with the Bordeaux parliament, Montaigne began working as a legal counselor in the chamber of inquiries, where all the cases too complicated for the judges to rule on immediately were sent. Montaigne’s job was to summarize both sides’ arguments in every case, and it is generally assumed that this is where he first learned to examine different and varied points of view. This is also likely where his distaste for scholarly interpretation and secondary sources came from.

France’s Civil Wars Left a Deep Mark on Montaigne’s Writing

Catherine de' Medici leaving her palace the morning after the St. Bartholomew's Day massacre. Photo source Wikipedia.
Catherine de’ Medici leaving her palace the morning after the St. Bartholomew’s Day massacre. Photo source Wikipedia.

During his many years at the parliament, Montaigne had the opportunity to closely examine human nature and the law. There he saw the human tendency to err, the constant lack of solid evidence, and the need for caution when passing judgment. He witnessed cases of both criminal violence and judicial violence, and grew deeply wary of both. During these years, Montaigne also took part in delegations to the Parlement of Paris and to the royal court. He personally met Henri II (r. 1547-1559), his heirs Charles IX (r. 1560-1574) and Henri III (r. 1574-1589), and their mother, the queen mother Catherine de’ Medici (1519-1589). His long stays in the capital and at the royal court also contributed to what he learned about human nature and power. As noted, it was a turbulent period, marked by frequent wars of religion and civil wars. The commonly accepted count is eight, although one could just as easily argue it was really one long war of religion with short ceasefires in between. Here is a partial list:

1562-1563: Began with the massacre of Protestants at Wassy, by the soldiers of the Duke de Guise. Ended with the Peace of Amboise.
1567-1568: Began with the massacre of Catholics at Nîmes, ended with the Peace of Longjumeau.
1568-1570: Began with renewed legislation against Protestant freedom of worship (the Edict of Saint-Maur), and ended with the Peace of Saint-Germain.
1572-1573: Began with the St. Bartholomew’s Day massacre and ended with the Peace of La Rochelle.

This pattern shows clearly just how large a role the civil wars played in Montaigne’s life. The eighth war, at the end of the 1580s, was the most dramatic of them all. The “War of the Three Henrys” was fought between a Catholic coalition (the League), led by Henri de Guise (1550-1588), the son of Duke François de Guise (1519-1563), who had commanded the massacre at Wassy and was murdered by a Huguenot assassin shortly afterward, and the Protestant coalition, led by Henri of Navarre (1553-1610). Caught in the middle, defending himself desperately against everyone, was Henri III (r. 1574-1589), the last king of the dying Valois dynasty. During this war, the king had the Duke de Guise murdered in his own chambers, and was himself murdered by a Catholic assassin. On his deathbed, he bequeathed his crown to Henri of Navarre, on condition that he convert to Catholicism. That decision was preceded by long, secret negotiations, in which the king and the Protestant leader used Montaigne as a go-between, perhaps the only man both of them trusted.

Death Is the Ultimate Essay

Statue of Montaigne, photo source Wikipedia
Statue of Montaigne, photo source Wikipedia

As if the wars of religion weren’t horror enough, they also came with outbreaks of plague. The plague of 1563 took from Montaigne his closest friend, the one person he considered a model of wisdom and conduct: Étienne de La Boétie, author of the world’s first anarchist essay, “Discourse on Voluntary Servitude.” It seems the “Essays” were originally planned as nothing more than a frame meant to surround La Boétie’s own literary and poetic work.

In 1565 he married Françoise de la Chassaigne, another strong-willed woman who claimed a firm hold on his life. The marriage seems to have been stable enough, but it brought him little comfort or joy: of their six children, only the second daughter survived.

The string of deaths in his life continued. After La Boétie, Montaigne lost his father, Pierre, in 1568. In the spring of 1569, one of his younger brothers, Arnaud, died after being struck lightly in the head by a tennis ball during a cheerful game. In June 1570, his first daughter was born, and she died two months later. Montaigne must have felt that death was closing in on him from every side. But by then, he had already understood what he needed to do to overcome his existential dread: he had to examine himself.

That realization came to him after an incident in which he himself came as close to death as possible. Sometime around 1569 or 1570, he went out riding near his château, accompanied by his servants. These were the days of civil war, so everyone traveled armed, but Montaigne, a small man, chose for once a small, docile horse, since the outing was meant to be short and close to home.

When he was violently thrown from his horse, he thought at first that he had been shot in some ambush. When he later managed to piece together what had happened from the carefully filtered testimony of his servants (he questioned them meticulously and cross-examined them one by one while lying on his sickbed), he discovered, to his surprise, that body and mind could be even more disconnected than he had thought. He was told that he had bled heavily and vomited without stop, that his hands had tried to tear off his jacket while he was completely unconscious. As soon as his awareness returned, he answered questions and gave instructions without being aware of doing so. All the way home he felt no pain at all, and only once his full consciousness returned did the pain and discomfort set in.

Montaigne carried out a careful interrogation of the witnesses to get the full picture of what had happened. It turned out that one of his servants, a large man on a large horse, had decided to show off in front of the others, broke into a gallop, and collided violently with his small master and his small horse (the other servants tried to protect him with vague answers, but Montaigne eventually managed to pry the truth out of them).

He now diagnosed that initial state, the numbness of the senses, as the closest thing to death, and the experience taught him not to fear that state. As Pliny the Elder put it: “Each of us is, for himself, an excellent subject of study, provided he is able to examine himself closely.”

All the Stoic and Epicurean philosophers he had loved since his youth had taught him that death is the ultimate exercise (which in French can be rendered as “essai,” the root of “essay”). But Montaigne resolved to devote himself to this kind of exercise from then on, and writing the Essays helped him improve himself, as long as he stayed honest with his readers.

Montaigne, Inventor of the Blog and the First Facebook Page

The famous tower at the Château de Montaigne where the Essays were written. Photo source Wikipedia.
The famous tower at the Château de Montaigne where the Essays were written. Photo source Wikipedia.

He had long since tired of political life. At the end of the Third War of Religion, Catholic Bordeaux, capital of the heavily Calvinist Guyenne region, was a particularly difficult place to maintain governance and the rule of law (he would later serve two terms as mayor there).

The peace of mind that was sometimes available to him at his château (which he divided between his wife, his mother and himself: one tower for him, one tower for Françoise, and his mother in between) tempted him to withdraw from public life and devote himself exclusively to writing.

In 1570 he sold his office, and on his 38th birthday, in February 1571, he had the following inscription carved into the library room of his tower:

“In the year of our Lord 1571, at the age of thirty-eight, on the last day of February, his birthday, long weary of the servitude of court and public office, and while still of sound mind, he retired to the bosom of the learned Muses, where, free of all cares, he will spend in peace what little remains of his life, already more than half spent. If fate allows, he will complete the building of this place, this sweet refuge in his ancestral home, and he dedicates it to his freedom, his peace of mind, and his leisure.”

The writing of the “Essays” had begun.

“To live is my occupation and my art,” he wrote, and anyone who takes the “Essays” for a how-to guide or a factual historical inquiry is mistaken. This book is the first blog, the world’s first Facebook page, entirely devoted to Montaigne’s examination of himself, of what unfolds within his own mind. He was, after all, the one who argued, paradoxically, that “judging by actions” can be misleading. Actions can be contingent, self-serving, and not necessarily drawn from the true nature of the person who performs them. “It is not my deeds that I set down, but myself, my essence.”

Related reading