Gaspard de Coligny: Martyred Saint or Murderous Warmonger?

|
Last updated:
|
Gaspard de Coligny: Martyred Saint or Murderous Warmonger?
Main menu
לקריאת הדף בעבריתThis page is also available in Hebrew

Today (August 24), marking 445 years since the St. Bartholomew’s Day Massacre and the same death anniversary of Gaspard II de Coligny (Gaspard de Coligny), Seigneur de Châtillon, let’s spend a few moments on historical subversion, take the measure of the devil’s advocate’s robe, and ask the ever-naive question: “what if?”

Because everyone, without exception, condemns the murder of the celebrated admiral, the revered leader of the Huguenots, and the massacre that followed, and rightly so. But somehow, everyone also tends to elegantly skip over the main reason for that murder, which happens to be quite juicy: Coligny was a warmonger.

Gaspard de Coligny on the right and his rival Henri de Guise on the left. Images: Wikipedia.
Gaspard de Coligny on the right and his rival Henri de Guise on the left. Images: Wikipedia.

Coligny Looks for War in the Antilles

Never mind his conduct during the French Wars of Religion: after all, he was no worse than his enemies, and did what everyone else did. His old friend François de Guise, leader of the Catholic faction, did exactly the same things, if not worse, until Coligny (or so everyone believed) ordered his assassination.

The thing is, even in times of peace, which was, let’s admit, the handiwork of Catherine de’ Medici and her diplomats, even then Coligny searched high and low for work to keep his Calvinist soldiers busy: “He knew the character of his Huguenots too well not to know that if you don’t keep them occupied and don’t direct their urges outward, they’ll turn to muddy the waters from within. Because he knew them as people lacking sense, restless, active, and great devotees of their main pastime.” So writes Pierre de Bourdeille, who claims these were the admiral’s own words to him.

Either way, starting with the Peace of Saint-Germain in 1570, Coligny relentlessly pushed the king toward war against Spain. The king, Charles IX, had just begun his youthful rebellion against his mother, whom he suspected (rightly) of favoring his brother, Duke Henri d’Anjou. Along with the mother, the entire body of royal advisors had lost its standing in the king’s eyes. And then Coligny suddenly appears, head of the Huguenot faction, a state within a state (with all the cities that had fallen into their hands under the Treaty of Saint-Germain), offering Charles the chance to win glory of his own, fight a righteous war, and step out of his mother’s shadow. No wonder Charles started addressing the admiral as “father,” and no wonder Catherine felt threatened by the admiral, not only personally but politically too: “Keep the peace in your policy, my son, it is useful and it is a duty,” she used to beg her impulsive son, again and again.

In July 1571, Coligny already sent up a trial balloon: a small flotilla sailed, with his blessing, to the Antilles on a reconnaissance mission, to scout the territory for the landing there of a larger French fleet. Unfortunately for them, the Huguenots got swept up in piracy in the area, drew the attention of the Spaniards, who trapped them in Santo Domingo and wiped them all out.

The Military Adventure That Almost Happened in the Low Countries

The main theater of operations, however, was planned for the Low Countries, then in the thick of the revolt against Philip II (Philippe II). Again, there’s no need to think that the entire future population of Holland and Belgium rose as one against the Spanish king: this was a civil war that turned into a religious war, Protestants against Catholics. The Huguenot faction had already signed an agreement with William of Orange (William d’Orange), promising that the French Protestants would intervene on behalf of their brothers in Flanders. Now, with the king under Coligny’s influence, the opportunity arose to draw all of France into this war.

The plan was to raise an army of 28,000 soldiers and, with help from England and the German Lutheran principalities, invade Flanders, where the local Protestants were supposed to open the gates of their cities to the French. The critics’ arguments against the plan: that it wasn’t worth tangling with the best army in the world; that the English and Germans, despite their initial support for the plan, would not, in the end, be happy about the Low Countries joining France; and that the Flemish and Dutch themselves would not be happy about it either, once they came to their senses and realized they had simply traded one foreign yoke for another.

All these arguments were flatly rejected by Coligny. “The wisest statesmen know for certain that a warlike people needs an external enemy, so as not to turn its weapons against itself. The national character of the Frenchman makes it hard for him to part with his weapon once he has first taken it up, and not to turn it against his own countrymen if he cannot use it against an outside enemy. The Italians, Germans and Swiss go home once peace is signed. But the Frenchman, who despises his home, his rest and all the arts, will go looking for war in another land, and if he has no opportunity to continue doing so, he will turn to banditry. To prevent this chaos in advance, we need a war abroad, one that is just, easy and profitable. The war I propose is a war against the king of Spain.” So wrote Coligny in a memorandum submitted to the king in 1572. In July, the Huguenot vanguard, 4,000 strong, already set out for Flanders, but suffered a stinging defeat there. Coligny, meanwhile, was busy preparing the main invasion force.

Catherine de' Medici leaving her palace the morning after the St. Bartholomew's Day Massacre. Image source: Wikipedia.
Catherine de’ Medici leaving her palace the morning after the St. Bartholomew’s Day Massacre. Image source: Wikipedia.

A Different Angle on the St. Bartholomew’s Day Massacre

Now, picture yourself in Catherine’s dark shoes: her son had gone completely mad and was flushing her life’s work down the drain. All she asked for was peace, and not only did he not want peace, but he was starting a war against the leading military and financial power in the world, and this while the string of terrible defeats at the hands of the Spanish was still fresh in the national memory. And the cause of this madness had a single name: Gaspard de Coligny.

Is it any surprise that she turned to the services of the assassin Charles de Louviers, better known as “Maurevert”? And when he missed his mark (just as he pulled the trigger, the admiral happened to bend down to adjust his boot) and created terrible unrest among the thousands of Huguenots who had come to the capital Paris for the wedding of Henri and Margot, unrest that could erupt at any moment into mass slaughter (it had happened before): is it still impossible to understand why she turned to the leaders of the Catholic faction, asking them to finish Maurevert’s job and eliminate all the “people lacking sense, restless, active, and great devotees of their main pastime”?

And when Coligny, mortally wounded by the Czech mercenary Karel Janowski z Janowicz (known to Parisians by his nickname “Besme”), was thrown by him out the window of his own house, down at the feet of the young Duke de Guise, son of his old friend, who had, it seems, been murdered on his orders: did he think, at that moment, “What if, instead of invading a foreign land, I had chosen peace after all?”

P.S. Coligny’s severed head was embalmed and sent as a gift to Pope Gregory XIII. The Holy Father was delighted.

Further reading: Château de Tanlay (Tanlay) in Burgundy, the château of Coligny’s younger brother, where the Huguenot leaders met at the start of the Wars of Religion.

Related reading