Today marks 701 years since the death of John I (15-20 November 1316), King of France and Navarre. If you have never heard of him, you should be a little ashamed, because this monarch holds quite a few royal records: he was the youngest French king in the entire history of the monarchy, and in fact the only one who was proclaimed king from the day of his birth. As a result, he is the only one who held that lofty title for the whole of his life. Five days, to be exact. That makes him the king with the shortest reign in French history, unless you count Louis XIX, who technically ruled for about 20 minutes on August 2, 1830 (between the moment his father, Charles X, signed away the throne, and the moment he signed an identical document himself). But no one ever saw Louis XIX as a legitimate king, while our John was a king in every sense of the word, at least in everyone’s eyes. Well, everyone except whoever apparently poisoned him. “Poisoned? A five-day-old baby?!” you ask. Well, France in the early fourteenth century was not an easy place for anyone, infant kings included. Hold on tight and try to keep up, because there are going to be a lot of Philips and Jeannes here (of both sexes).
The Curse of the Templars
To really understand the situation, we need to go back two kings, to the unfortunate baby’s grandfather: Philip IV (r. 1285-1314), known as “the Fair” and “the Iron King.” Everything seemed to go his way. He strengthened the French monarchy more than any king before him, bent popes and overly independent feudal lords in his kingdom to his will, and when he felt strong enough, he crushed the Knights Templar, burned their leaders, and seized their treasures. Along the way, he also seized the treasures of the Jews in his kingdom and then expelled them. One unpleasant detail: standing at the stake, the head of the Templar order cursed the king and his dynasty, or so the popular legend goes. But in the meantime, everything kept going his way, including matters of succession. Philip had three grown, healthy, married sons, and his heir, Louis, already had a first daughter, which meant the Capetian kings’ fertility was holding up nicely into the next generation.

And then the curse started to work. First, it came out that the wife of the heir to the throne and the wife of the youngest son, Marguerite and Blanche, were committing adultery, while the wife of the middle son, Jeanne, was helping them carry it out. The scandal was enormous: the princesses’ lovers were executed publicly and gruesomely, the adulterous princesses were locked up in the grim fortress of Château Gaillard, and the accomplice was placed under house arrest on her mother’s estate. Luckily for her, her husband, Prince Philip, insisted on her innocence, and eventually won her a full acquittal, and she was allowed to return to his arms and to the royal court. Meanwhile, King Philip IV died suddenly on November 29, 1314, apparently of a stroke, despite his robust health. The Templars’ curse kept on working. Louis X (r. 1314-1316), “the Quarreler,” took the throne: a weak king, easily swayed by those close to him, and an unpleasant, not especially bright man in general, although he did let the Jews return to France.
Louis’s greatest wish was to get rid of his imprisoned, disgraced wife and remarry. As for their daughter, little Jeanne, he simply disowned her, declaring her illegitimate and not his, though he never bothered to put that in any official document. It seems the new king’s prayers fell on attentive ears: Marguerite died in her cell just days before his coronation, under more than suspicious circumstances, and less than a week after her death he married Princess Clementia of the Hungarian royal house, so both of them were crowned together. Half a year later, the queen became pregnant. Everything looked wonderfully promising, but on June 5, 1316, Louis died suddenly. The official story blamed wine that was too cold, which the king drank too much of after an especially grueling game of tennis (by the way, Louis X is the first tennis player we know by name; there you go, fans of the white sport, you can thank me later). But there were also fairly loud whispers about poison, and fingers were quietly pointed at one of the most powerful and exalted feudal lords in the kingdom, Mahaut, Countess of Artois and Burgundy, aunt of the late Marguerite and mother of Blanche and Jeanne. Mahaut had excellent reasons to despise Louis (he had backed her unruly nephew Robert, who wanted to seize the county of Artois from her) and to try to clear the throne for her daughter Jeanne and her beloved son-in-law Philip. Mahaut was known as a woman who did not stop at red lights, so no one dared cross her, and the whole thing ended in whispers. But we already know that curses from burned Templars tend to work.
From the 14th Century Straight to Game of Thrones
And here a succession problem arose, for the first time since the dynasty’s founder, Hugh Capet: it was not clear who should inherit the throne. In principle, it should have been Jeanne’s turn, the young daughter of the late Louis and Marguerite. But Louis had made a point of shouting to anyone willing to listen that he did not consider her a legitimate daughter, and his brother Philip went even further and hired sharp lawyers who dug up, out of the depths of obscurity, the “Salic Law,” which held that the ancient Frankish tribes never allowed women to inherit the throne. Doubts about her legitimacy, and the conveniently discovered “precedent,” pushed the girl away from power, but Philip’s problems were not over yet: after all, the widowed queen was pregnant, and if she gave birth to a son, he would be crowned king. Which is exactly what happened, and that is how we got to John I, who was immediately given the nickname “the Posthumous.”
In the meantime, Philip settled for the role of regent, though that may not have satisfied Countess Mahaut. At the ceremony presenting John to the French nobility, Mahaut was given the honor of holding the baby in her arms, and he, surprise, surprise, died a few minutes later (opinions differ on whether it was poison smeared on his lips or nostrils, or a long, thick needle in his soft skull). And just like that, who do we find sitting so comfortably on the French throne? None other than Philip V (r. 1316-1322), “the Tall,” and his loyal wife Jeanne! Jacques de Molay, who cursed the king before his terrible death, must have been rubbing his hands with glee in the afterlife. Why? Because Philip died of illness after only five years of a wise and very successful reign. The “Salic Law” he himself had invented screwed over his own daughters, who were pushed aside to clear the line of succession for his younger brother, Charles IV (r. 1322-1328). Charles, too, left no male heirs, so when he died six years later, the direct Capetian line came to an end, and the crown passed to the House of Valois (descendants of Charles of Valois, brother of Philip IV the Fair). The new king, Philip VI (r. 1328-1350), was married to Jeanne “the Lame,” that same rejected daughter of Louis X and Marguerite of Burgundy, so she did get to be queen after all.
By the way, the “Salic Law” was later used as a pretext to reject the claims of Edward III (r. 1327-1377), King of England, whose mother, Isabella, was a daughter of Philip IV, which meant her rights, and her son’s rights, were arguably greater than those of his cousins. When the French refused to show the English envoys this “ancient” law, insisting that if a woman could not inherit the throne of France, she certainly could not pass it on either, the English envoys reportedly wondered, puzzled, “Are the kings of France not born of women?” Funny as it sounds, this was the direct, official trigger for the outbreak of the Hundred Years’ War. The Templars, hiding out across western Europe, must have been quite pleased. So pleased that, as the story goes, when Louis XVI (r. 1774-1792) was beheaded during the French Revolution, someone in the crowd shouted: “Jacques de Molay, your revenge is complete!”
This story has one tragic postscript. In the middle of the Hundred Years’ War, while the King of France, John II (r. 1350-1364, House of Valois, remember?), sat captive in England, an Italian man named Giannino Baglioni turned up in Provence, claiming to be none other than John I (House of Capet, remember?), who had supposedly survived. He said that people close to Clementia had feared an attempt on the baby’s life and had switched him with another infant without even telling the widowed queen, and that he, Baglioni, had only recently discovered his true origins. Historians tend to think he was an impostor, a tool in the hands of the populist Roman leader Cola di Rienzo. But one thing we do know: Louis I of Hungary (r. 1342-1382), Clementia’s nephew, agreed to meet Baglioni at his court and recognized him as his cousin. Either way, in 1360 he was imprisoned in Naples and died in jail three years later.
So, friends, remember poor John I, and go read The Accursed Kings by Maurice Druon, the true inspiration behind George R. R. Martin. That is a genuinely great series of historical novels, and there, this whole story, and many others, are told a thousand times more vividly.
Related reading