When the painting “Luncheon on the Grass” was shown at the “Salon des Refusés”, the French public was stunned. Men quickly steered their wives away from the painting, then came back to look at it again, intending to laugh at it and mock it. The painting was the work of Édouard Manet (1832-1883), who is considered today one of the most recognized French artists, a painter who contributed enormously to the birth of modern art. But to the French of his own time, he was seen as a rebel.

The academic painting of the 19th century
In 1863, the most important art exhibition in Paris was called the “Salon”. It was the official art exhibition organized by the Académie des Beaux-Arts and sponsored by the government. It was held at the Palais de l’Industrie in Paris, and it was the only exhibition that was open to the general public at the time. The works shown at the exhibition were selected by forty judges, some of whom were appointed by the government, so their decisions reflected the government’s wishes and largely dictated the style of art in France, and to a great extent in all of Europe. The judges chose to show works at “the Salon” on religious, historical and mythological subjects, along with landscapes and portraits. For visitors to the exhibition, mostly government officials and the bourgeoisie, it was a kind of show. They came to see and to be seen, and they knew that a painting bought at “the Salon” was a safe investment.
Every artist who wanted recognition dreamed of showing at this exhibition. At a time when photography had just been invented, newspapers carried only a few black-and-white illustrations, private galleries barely existed, and museums displayed only works from the past, the Salon was a wonderful opportunity to reach a large audience and become known. One example of the popular, official artistic taste of the period is the painting by Alexandre Cabanel (1823-1889), “The Birth of Venus”. The painting was a great success at the Salon in 1863, and was purchased immediately by Napoleon III for his own personal collection.

At the art schools of the time, drawing the nude from life was considered an important stage of training, but it was only acceptable to paint a female nude when she was presented as a mythological, allegorical or oriental figure. That way, an idealized body could be shown without doing too much damage to public morals. Cabanel, like many artists, used mythology as a pretext to show a naked woman in a way that would look decent enough to his contemporaries.
Cabanel was so well regarded that he was chosen as one of the Salon’s judges, and he was one of the people who refused to let Manet and other painters show their work at the 1863 Salon. That year, the Salon’s judges rejected so many works that Napoleon III decided to step in and opened a parallel exhibition called the “Salon des Refusés”. It was there that Manet’s painting “Luncheon on the Grass” was shown. The painting became the center of attention at the exhibition and caused a great uproar.
Luncheon on the Grass
The painting shows several figures having a picnic in the Bois de Boulogne, which was one of the popular leisure spots of the time. In the center are two carefully dressed men, wearing the typical clothing of the upper bourgeoisie. The man on the right was based on Manet’s brother Gustave, while the man on the left was based on the sculptor and Manet’s future brother-in-law, Ferdinand Leenhoff. Beside them sits Victorine Meurent, Manet’s favorite model, shown here as a nude woman looking directly at the viewer.
In the background, another woman, wearing only her white slip, is wading in the cool waters of the Seine. In the foreground: the blue dress and straw hat of one of the women, a picnic basket, and the remains of the picnic: cherries, brioche rolls (considered an expensive, refined food at the time), and an empty glass bottle. They had already drunk everything.

268.5×208 cm, Musée d’Orsay, Paris. Image source: Wikipedia.
Manet was convinced the public would love the painting because he based it on Giorgione’s (c. 1477-1510) “The Pastoral Concert”, which was then at the Louvre. That painting also shows an idealized scene in a beautiful rural landscape, with two dressed men and two nude women who are mythological muses.

The painting also resembles a work by Raphael (1483-1520), which Manet saw through an engraving that was then at the Louvre, depicting the mythological story of the “Judgment of Paris“, where in the bottom right corner there are two river gods and a nymph.

But the visitors to the “Salon des Refusés” were shocked. The painting caused a media uproar and fierce opposition: Napoleon III and his wife, who visited the exhibition, said it was an unprecedented attack on decency, while others claimed they had never seen such an indecent painting. They laughed, grew angry, protested and took offense.
So what exactly shocked the Parisians about “Luncheon on the Grass”?
Viewers argued that the scattered food showed contempt for bourgeois values. On top of that, Manet made no attempt to hide his brushstrokes: the painting even looked unfinished in certain areas, and he painted the women in a glaring white that created a strong, unnatural sense of lighting, one that people of the time found dazzling and that flattened the figures.

Manet painted an everyday subject, a picnic out in nature, on a large canvas usually reserved for historical, religious and mythological themes. These are not idealized figures but Parisians out for a day off, people one might run into on the streets of Paris. For the first time, a female nude was painted in an everyday setting. In Giorgione’s painting, the figures are mythological muses, so their nudity is pure, unrealistic and not provocative. Here, by contrast, this is a real woman. We don’t see a nipple or any body hair, but her build is a bit sturdy: she is a modern Parisian woman who undressed on a hot summer day. Manet claimed she was looking at the viewer calmly, but the public said her expression was brazen and shameless, that her gaze was direct and inviting, and made clear she knew she was being watched. That knowledge put the viewer in the uncomfortable position of a voyeur.
What bothered viewers most was the fact that the men in the painting paid no attention to the nude woman beside them, or to her friend bathing in the background. That lack of attention, combined with the men being fully dressed in the middle of a forest clearing, only heightened the sense of blatant eroticism in the eyes of viewers, and suggested a hint of a dubious kind of outing: two Parisian women spending time with their lovers. The scene raised thoughts of sex, and in 1863, sex was taboo. Sexual relations were only permitted in the bedroom of a married couple or behind closed doors. The painting broke the rules of propriety, and in doing so, violated one of the most important rules of bourgeois society.
It’s hard to pin down exactly what the painting is really about, and that’s part of its fascination. One interpretation is that it depicts the prostitution that was rampant at the time in the Bois de Boulogne, a large park on the western edge of Paris. That kind of prostitution was well known in Paris, but it was considered a taboo subject, not a fitting one for a painting. Manet’s real intention was to quote from the art of the past in order to challenge it, to rebel against it. He wanted to show that an artist did not have to paint a perfect ideal of beauty according to the rules of the Academy. He wanted to shock the public by showing people he knew engaged in an everyday leisure activity, in order to depict the life of the new urban person. With this painting, Manet made a clear statement: he was the one who would decide what his art would look like.
Édouard Manet, caught between rebellion and bourgeois life
Manet was deeply disappointed by the public’s reaction. The scandal made him famous, but Manet came from a wealthy, well-connected bourgeois family. His father was a successful judge. His brother Gustave, who modeled as one of the figures in the painting, became a lawyer, a member of the Paris city council, and inspector general of prisons.
Manet’s father only agreed to let him study painting after he failed the entrance exams to the navy twice. In the bourgeois circle his family belonged to, a career as an artist seemed synonymous with social decline. “Poor as an artist” was a common saying at the time. Manet studied for several years in the studio of Thomas Couture, one of the most important academic painters of the period. But over time he came to believe that an artist should paint what he actually saw, the world of his own time, the way he did in this painting.
Manet, who never compromised in his art, suffered in his private life. To avoid causing a scandal, he always dressed formally, in a black suit and gloves, and was accompanied by a dog, which was then a status symbol of the upper class. He respected the conventions of his time so strictly that for 13 years he hid his mistress, the Dutch piano teacher Suzanne Leenhoff, in a small apartment in Paris. Only in 1863, the same year he painted this picture, and after his father’s death, did Manet decide to marry Suzanne. He never acknowledged the son born of their affair: he always presented the boy as his wife’s younger brother. This was in stark contrast to the boldness he showed in his art.
No one wanted to buy Manet’s painting; public taste remained conservative. The bourgeoisie shied away from any risk or innovation in art. Buyers did not want a true depiction of reality, they wanted idealized, sweet paintings. Luckily for Manet, the money he inherited from his father allowed him to express his views and his protest without having to worry about making a living.
Édouard Manet died at age 51, after suffering from syphilis and rheumatism. The painting that caused such a scandal in its time became one of the most recognized and beloved paintings in the history of art, and one of the forerunners of modern art. So it’s hardly surprising that it’s on display today at the Musée d’Orsay in Paris, and has become a source of inspiration for countless artists.
Enjoyed the article? Want to read more?
- If you’d like to read more about Manet, I highly recommend Dr. Orna Lieberman’s article about his relationship with the painter Berthe Morisot.
- If you’ve decided to visit Paris and see Manet’s paintings in person, I strongly recommend buying your ticket to the Musée d’Orsay in advance to skip the line.
Related reading