Théodore Géricault’s The Raft of the Medusa

|
Last updated:
|
Théodore Géricault’s The Raft of the Medusa
Main menu
לקריאת הדף בעבריתThis page is also available in Hebrew

Théodore Géricault’s The Raft of the Medusa refers to a harsh and frightening scandal that took place in the period after Napoleon, when the monarchy was temporarily restored in France. In June 1816, the frigate Méduse set sail with three other ships from the French royal navy, heading for the port of Saint-Louis in the colony of Senegal. The colony had been handed over to the French by the British as a gesture of goodwill toward the French king Louis XVIII (r. 1814-1815, 1815-1824), who had just been restored to his throne. About 400 people were on board, including the new governor of Senegal and his soldiers, along with 160 crew members. The 53-year-old captain, who hadn’t been to sea in 25 years and had never once commanded a ship, got the job purely because of his social standing as a nobleman and his ties to the Bourbon royal family.

Wanting to cover the distance in a reasonable time, the incompetent captain hugged the coastline and quickly overtook the other ships, only to run aground on a sandbank, which came as no surprise. The sailors tried to throw excess weight overboard, hoping to lift the ship off the muddy bottom and free it with the tide, but the captain, fearful of his employers back in France, refused to get rid of the heavy cannons. In the end, everyone was forced to abandon the sinking ship. The captain kept the six lifeboats for himself, the senior officers and their families, and lowered about 149 French passengers and junior crew members (including one woman) onto a makeshift wooden raft tied to one of the boats.

The original plan was apparently to tow the raft, but the hopeless idea was quickly abandoned, and once the towline was released, the raft’s passengers were left adrift on the open sea. And so, without food or water, the raft was tossed about for 13 days, during which the starving survivors experienced violence, murder, madness, and eventually even turned to cannibalism. The fifteen men who survived the horrific ordeal finally spotted a ship on the horizon, the Argus, which was searching for the wreckage of the Méduse, hoping to recover some of the gold bars it had carried. They signaled it with what strength they had left, but the ship didn’t notice them and continued on its way.
The painting captures that very moment as described by one of the survivors: the moment the survivors’ hope turned into panic and despair. Luckily, the Argus turned back, as if by miracle, two hours later, and rescued the survivors.

Meanwhile, the captain and the rest of the command crew managed to reach the shores of Africa and from there made their way back to France, where they were arrested on charges of dereliction of duty and put on trial between 1816 and 1817 (and later acquitted). The trial of the captain and his crew, which played out alongside the shocking accounts published in a pamphlet by two of the survivors, the engineer Alexandre Corréard and the surgeon Henri Savigny, became a major news story and an international scandal.

Théodore Géricault
Théodore Géricault

Théodore Géricault and the creation of the Raft

At that time, Jean Louis André Théodore Géricault (1791-1824), a young and ambitious 25-year-old painter, was looking for a subject dramatic, convincing and serious enough to launch his career with one bold stroke of the brush, the way the painting Oath of the Horatii had done for his fellow painter Jacques-Louis David (1748-1825). Following the recent trend of engaging with political subjects that David had set, Géricault chose as his subject the harsh experience of French citizens abandoned by their own captain. For Géricault, the story revealed humanity’s darkest nature, and gave expression to the social conditions that still prevailed in France.

As the son of a well-off bourgeois family, Géricault was disappointed by the outcomes of the French Revolution, and couldn’t stand the unchecked dominance and privileges still held by the nobility. Géricault found himself caught in this delicate tension between the rights of the old world and those of the modern one. On one hand, Géricault’s wealth gave him the financial freedom to pursue his artistic interests and indulge his passion for horseback riding without constraint. On the other hand, in the year before he began working on the painting, Géricault became acquainted with the pro-Bonapartist bourgeois community in the Montmartre neighborhood, where he lived in Paris. The friendship Géricault developed with Corréard and Savigny, and the influence of the pamphlet the two published, marked the beginning of Géricault’s search for the true meaning of the shipwreck, and a hidden way to express his moral and political protest. The power of the raft as a tool of political propaganda wasn’t necessarily the most important subject for Géricault, but it undoubtedly stood out amid the general atmosphere prevailing in France.

A divided France: Napoleon’s supporters against the Bourbon Restoration

France at the time was still deeply divided between liberal factions and monarchists, and the trial became a battleground between the two sides over the question of restoring the monarchy. The fact that the holder of the royal appointment saved himself and other aristocrats while abandoning 150 ordinary citizens to certain death became a kind of parable for the nobility’s privilege, and gave the republican factions plenty of ammunition. They painted a similar picture of the corrupt, incompetent Bourbon monarchist government, cruelly abandoning the French people. Here, the republican critics drew on the well-known political maritime metaphor (from Plato’s Republic) of the “good leader” wisely steering the “ship of state.” For Napoleon’s veteran soldiers, who had been pushed out of their positions in favor of courtiers like the captain, the Medusa disaster summed up the state of France under the Bourbon dynasty: a parable for the nobility’s exploitation and its meager talent.

Louis XVIII
Louis XVIII

Censorship and political controversy

The Salon of 1819, held under Louis XVIII, was meant to express the greatness of the Bourbon dynasty through the exhibition he patronized. Unlike the classical subjects of the French school of David that had come before, the renovated Louvre filled from wall to wall with paintings of piety and religion, depictions in a medieval style that aligned with the idea of church and monarchy by the grace of God. Most artists who couldn’t afford the enormous cost of the giant canvases had to rely on patrons, who were usually tied to the royal house. As the son of an established bourgeois family, Géricault could bear the financial burden himself, and managed to escape this kind of censorship.

After dozens of preparatory sketches, Géricault settled on the right moment for the painting’s subject: the moment the survivors try to catch the attention of the distant ship, but in vain. On a massive canvas nearly 7 by 5 meters, Géricault presented, in the Grand Salon of the Louvre, a work that was instantly recognized for its controversial subject, at a time of political upheaval. Not surprisingly, to avoid a political scandal, the painting’s title was changed at the exhibition to “Scene of a Shipwreck” (Scène de Naufrage), and the direct reference to the political event of the Medusa disaster was dropped. Even so, it was the single large painting in the Salon that stood in complete contrast to David’s heroic works, and it expressed a very personal opinion, at a time when “to speak of the Medusa was to embarrass the royal house.”

Jacques-Louis David: Oath of the Horatii
Jacques-Louis David: Oath of the Horatii

Classicism and modernism: French Romanticism

Géricault took his first steps in the same style as the French school, during a period when Napoleon’s patronage provided both the financial foundation and the victories that served as subject matter for many artists.
But with Napoleon’s fall, both the patronage and the subjects vanished. So the ambitious artist traveled to Rome to see and study the classical artists firsthand. Awed by their great skill in depicting figures, Géricault longed for an alternative that would break the “tedium” of paintings about antiquity, religion or the monarchy. Géricault found that alternative in the harsh reality of modernization. He wanted to preserve the classical anatomical precision of Michelangelo and his peers, as well as the universal appeal of a subject that would speak to the general public. The problem he faced was how to give classical form to everyday reality, or in other words, how to “translate a fresh, current event, like this morning’s news, into a painting on a superhuman scale.” Or how to choose between the modern and the monumental.

But instead of choosing one and giving up the other, Géricault combined them into “an entirely new form of modern history painting,” a style that eventually came to be known as French Romanticism, and which gave the raft he created its historical importance. Géricault’s distinctive style, especially as seen in the Raft, was tied to his ability to combine the monumental quality of the classical style with modern nationalism and heroism, while at the same time realistically depicting the anti-heroic nature of life. The paintings were of people and spoke to people, and the painting’s massive size matched the tradition of historical painting and suited the Louvre.

The composition of the painting
The composition of the painting

Analyzing the work

Théodore Géricault’s extreme use of perspective in building this unconventional composition served both the viewer and the lower-class figures depicted in the painting. By bringing the raft close to the front, Géricault made the viewer complicit. The viewer’s eye follows the survivors straining toward the point on the horizon, the Argus, without knowing whether the ship is approaching or disappearing. Géricault uses a hierarchical, pyramidal composition: the fifteen survivors are arranged as a human pyramid that mirrors the threatening wave rising on the left. The different human conditions are shown in gradual stages, from the dying and despairing bodies in the foreground to the peak of hope embodied by the Black man waving toward the ship on the horizon. That Black figure, representing the lowest class, stands at the top of the pyramid.

The composition is built on diagonal lines created by the movement of the people, the sail and the outline of the raft. These diagonals cut across the surface and convey a sense of instability, sharpening the contrast between the horror and despair of some figures and the hope of others. The multiplication of diagonals also emphasizes a dynamic, emotionally charged movement, as the figures face different directions while the raft drifts over the stormy sea. The people on the raft fall into four groups: the dead and dying at the center, those struggling to rise, a third group of three figures huddled together by the mast in expressive poses, and a fourth group surrounding the African man waving the flag. Looking at the painting from left to right, we notice that the physical intensity of the figures’ movements grows. The figures in the foreground are tormented and show clear despair, while the faces of the more active figures are somewhat blurred, hidden in shadow, and some are not visible at all.

Like his fellow Romantics and his Neoclassical predecessors, Géricault was strongly influenced by the way figures were depicted in the paintings of Michelangelo and in Baroque painting. The figures are rendered with great anatomical precision, idealized and muscular, clean-shaven, with no sign of the wounds or blood that would have actually been present. At the same time, the figures’ poses are twisted and contorted in various states of exhaustion, set against somber colors and sharp contrasts of light and shadow that supply the drama the scene demands. The figures, shown at their lowest point, emphasize the insignificance of man before the forces of nature, running counter to the Neoclassical emphasis on restraint and heroism. Vulnerable man is a victim, not a hero. The mood of the work is filled with pain, suffering and despair, and the depictions of death and extreme despair are shown in their full ugliness, without embellishment or idealization.

The Romantic-style sky and ocean convey tremendous drama and create a sense of the overwhelming forces at whose mercy human beings are placed, forces that Géricault studied for an entire year. Géricault’s precise anatomical rendering of these grotesque figures served another purpose: to place the viewer in the position of the survivors and draw them into an emotional, empathetic connection with their struggle. It’s also worth noting that the painting contains twenty figures, not fifteen. Death lurks in every corner of the painting. The horror comes not from scenes of mutiny, cannibalism or chaos, but from the knowledge that what we are looking at are the results of the shocking, bloody event that just occurred, an event that would forever scar the lives of the survivors, leaving behind the memory of the horrors that took place. The viewer picks up on this through the blood-stained ax head on the right side of the painting, the headless body of the figure in the foreground on the right, the upper body of the man in the upper left of the painting, his rotted and swollen hand, the gaping wound beneath his ribs, and the absence of his lower body. All of these offer chilling hints of the original carnage.

And yet death also dwells among the living, as with the Black man on the right side of the painting, whose mouth rests against the buttocks of the young red-haired figure, and the grieving father figure, sitting and holding the body of his dead son.
Early sketches of the painting reveal the development of the father figure, who was originally drawn by Géricault as a feral cannibal and later became the father mourning his son. The father’s face may express not only grief but also remorse.
The blood-stained bandage on his left arm hints at the state in which his animal instinct took over, intensifying the revulsion of a man who ate the flesh and blood of his own son (as if eating his own body, as the bandage suggests).

The Raft of the Medusa allowed Géricault to paint modern life as a fascinating mixture of cruelty and heroic struggle, despair and hope, destruction and redemption. Géricault managed to give the painting a meaning far broader than a mere social or political issue. This universal landscape painting emphasized the human struggle against nature. Here, the Romantic style focused on the tragic suffering of human beings, the wrecked ship standing in for all of civilization, which had descended into a savage, cannibalistic situation. It was a new and authentic Romantic condition that exposed the darkest side of human nature, mocking the ideas of the Enlightenment and Rousseau about the noble savage and about nature as a just and proper foundation for morality.

Géricault and the pursuit of truth

Géricault, the archetype of the suffering, rage-filled Romantic artist, expressed his disappointments and feelings about what was happening around him, in nature and in society. His work was, on the one hand, full of drama and emotion, and on the other, carefully planned and the product of deliberate judgment. Géricault rarely invented things out of pure imagination; he always sought a fresh source of inspiration from life itself, often exposing himself to raw experience to sharpen his sense of the harsh reality of the subjects he painted. The political events of his time aligned with a period of personal despair in his life that relentlessly pulled him toward the terrible and the macabre. In a feverish solitude that lasted a year and a half, driven by an unrelenting obsession, he researched the subject from every angle and made countless sketches. He visited the hospitals and morgues of Paris to study and sketch the expressions of the dying and the dead, and he traveled to the coast of Normandy to observe the sea and sky and study the movement of the water. In his exhaustive search for information about the wrecked ship, he enlisted the Medusa’s own carpenter to build him a scale model of the raft, on which he modeled the figures of the survivors in wax, and he assembled “a dossier packed with evidence and authentic documents.”

Géricault went to extraordinary lengths to recreate the reality the survivors had lived through.
After shaving his head, he withdrew to a new studio, and to study the destructive effects of illness and despair on the human body, he brought corpses and body parts into the studio to experience the sights and smells of decomposing human flesh, just as the survivors of the raft had done when they kept pieces of the dead in order to survive. Géricault also used live models. He asked his friend, the painter Eugène Delacroix, to pose for him (the figure facing downward with arms spread at the center of the composition), along with two of the actual survivors, Henri Savigny and Alexandre Corréard, who appear at the foot of the mast. This multilayered gathering of information, which tied the event to the painting in hundreds of ways, ended paradoxically in a painting largely stripped of specific references, one that in fact created a more universal image of human loss.

Class struggle and the fight against racism

Géricault’s painting linked the question of class to that of race, by including three Black men among the survivors and by placing one Black man above all the other survivors on the raft, like a lighthouse of hope.
In Géricault’s time, the monarchy referred to slaves as “dark-skinned mules” and treated the slave trade as a viable economic tool. It was no accident that Géricault placed a Black man at the peak of hope, at the top of the pyramid.
The horrifying accounts from Corréard, who reported on the thriving slave trade in Senegal carried out under the protection of French authorities, deeply affected Géricault, who was shaken by the discovery that slavery had been a hidden motive behind the Medusa’s voyage. And so, Géricault not only expresses a moral and political critique of the abandonment of the raft’s passengers, but also takes a stand against slavery, by painting the survivors of a ship whose unofficial purpose had been to help re-establish the French slave trade on an island off the coast of Senegal.

Sadly, Géricault’s next project, meant to be a monumental work on “the treatment of Black people,” was never completed because of his declining health, brought on by tuberculosis and the deep depression from which he suffered. Géricault’s painting style, shaped throughout his life by cycles of depression and despair and a fascination with images of ruin and destruction, along with the tragic manner of his death at age 33, after falling from a galloping horse, made him the archetype of the Romantic painter.

Related reading