Today (October 16, 2017), 224 years ago, at 12:15 p.m., Marie Antoinette (1755-1793) was beheaded in the Place de la Révolution in Paris (later renamed the Place de la Concorde).
There’s much debate about the queen’s personality and her role in the fall of the French monarchy, but few dispute that her final months were filled with suffering, both physical and emotional, which she faced with courage and dignity. There’s almost no debate that the people who tormented her were among the worst of humanity, and none at all that she met her death as a queen should.
As much as I’m not a fan of looking at history through a gender lens, it’s hard not to notice the stark difference between the treatment her husband, Louis XVI (r. 1774-1792), received before his death, and the treatment she was given. It seems her womanhood itself stirred some extra level of vindictiveness in her captors.
Marie Antoinette’s Trial
First, there’s a difference in the reason for the execution. In Louis’s case, there was a formal charge of treason, and his execution was a legislative act of the Convention. In her case, the radical revolutionaries simply needed a victim to seal a blood pact between themselves and the Parisian mob, the sans-culottes, as the coalition army closed in on the French capital.
Other candidates for the role of victim, the Girondins, had already been eliminated by that point. The first to demand Marie Antoinette’s head was Jacques Hébert (1757-1794), the most radical of the radicals, who put it to the delegates in no uncertain terms: “I promised Antoinette’s head. I will go cut it off myself if you delay handing it over. I promised it in your name to the sans-culottes who demand it, and without them, you will cease to exist.”

Second, Louis XVI and his team of lawyers were given time to prepare a defense. Marie Antoinette and her lawyers were given one day. Third, there’s no comparison between the nature of the charges brought against him and what was claimed against her in court. Naturally, Hébert outdid everyone else. He was close to Antoine Simon, the chief jailer of the Temple prison, where Marie Antoinette was held along with her daughter, her son and her sister-in-law.
After eight-year-old Louis-Charles was physically torn from his mother and handed over to the care of the jailer, Simon, a former shoemaker, “to be educated in the spirit of the revolution.” Louis-Charles, who after his father’s death had technically become Louis XVII (1785-1795), was far from being a king even in potential. His entire conscious life had been spent moving from one prison to another, and the boy developed a genuine desire to please his jailers.
Now, having fallen into the hands of the brute Simon, who introduced a thrilling new element into his life, namely savage beatings for disciplinary infractions, the boy became a broken vessel. And when Simon told Hébert that he had caught the boy masturbating, the two revolutionaries pounced on the news as if they had struck gold. It didn’t take them much time or effort to extract from the boy a confession that the ones who had taught him to do it were his mother and his aunt, “who used to put him in bed between them and…”
During her lightning trial, which lasted a day and a half, Marie Antoinette conducted herself with cold, detached restraint, answering questions in brief, laconic terms. When Hébert voiced his accusations, she didn’t bother responding. When one of the jurors asked why she wasn’t reacting to Hébert’s charges and the judge demanded she answer, she abandoned her composure and replied with fury: “If I did not answer, it is because nature itself refuses to answer such a charge when it is brought against a mother. I appeal to all the mothers present here.”
A menacing commotion swept through the women in the crowd, and the market women of Paris, perhaps the queen’s loudest haters, could not help but take her side. They began shouting that the trial had to be stopped right then and there. The outrageous accusation that Hébert and Simon had concocted nearly backfired on them. Only with great difficulty did the judge manage to calm the crowd and continue the proceedings.
The End of a Queen
Fourth, Louis was surrounded by loved ones. His personal priest accompanied him to the scaffold, and he was even given the chance to say goodbye to his wife and children. Marie Antoinette, by the end, was completely alone. She was moved from the Temple to the Conciergerie prison, where she lived in very poor conditions, under the constant watch of guards who never left her room.
When she wanted to change clothes or use the bathroom, she would set up a cloth partition between herself and them. On the day of her execution, even that was denied her. She was forced to change clothes and sanitary bandages in front of them, and they didn’t take their eyes off her even when she asked to use the bathroom. The priest brought to her was one of the Republican clergy, whom she considered illegitimate, and she refused to speak with him or confess to him before her death.

Fifth, while Louis was driven to his scaffold in a closed carriage, she was taken on an open cart, her hands bound behind her back, facing the direction of travel, nearly falling at every turn. She was driven through the streets, exposed to the insults and spit of the mob (nothing actually hit her, but she saw it all). And despite all this, she climbed the scaffold with dignity. She accidentally stepped on the foot of the executioner, Charles-Henri Sanson (1739-1806), and her last words were words of gentleness and apology: “I am sorry, I did not do it on purpose.”
Jacques Hébert, on the other hand, when less than six months later he fell out with Maximilien Robespierre (1758-1794) and was himself led to the scaffold, squealed like a pig being slaughtered, wet himself and fainted several times on the way from the cart to the guillotine. His executioners, unlike Sanson, did not treat him with any respect, and sabotaged the mechanism so that the blade stopped three times just inches from Hébert’s neck, making him break into fresh screams of terror each time. His wife was executed twenty days after him.
Want to Read More About Marie Antoinette?
- Ariella Goichman-Garber, a fashion blogger, wrote about her influence on today’s fashion world.
- Orly Oren, a lecturer in art history, wrote about the painter she admired, Élisabeth Vigée Le Brun (1755-1842).
- And of course, you can also walk through Versailles in her footsteps.
Related reading