The Disappearance of the “Black Mozart”: The Story of the Chevalier de Saint-Georges

|
Last updated:
|
The Disappearance of the “Black Mozart”: The Story of the Chevalier de Saint-Georges

Had he been white, Joseph Bologne, Chevalier de Saint-Georges (1739-1799), might be as famous and revered today as his contemporary Mozart. In his time, he was the most gifted violinist around, a prolific and successful composer, Europe’s leading orchestra conductor, and also the finest fencer of his generation, a star of high society’s gatherings, and a favorite of upper-class women.

“The Black man of the Enlightenment,” they called him, with a kind of admiration. But Saint-Georges was a man of mixed race with dark skin, and as usual, racism won out over talent and fame. Even his memory sank into oblivion. The “Black man” had served his purpose, and was erased.

The story of the man known as the “Black Mozart” is a fascinating and little-known example of an important aspect of French relations with the other: attitudes toward Black people. It also shows the double standard of the French Revolution, which preached freedom and equality it did not practice fairly, when it came to the status of Black people and people of mixed race, and to the vile institution of slavery, which it chose not to abolish, but rather to perpetuate!

Joseph Bologne, Chevalier de Saint-Georges. Photo source: Wikipedia
Joseph Bologne, Chevalier de Saint-Georges. Photo source: Wikipedia

A book published in 1999, written by journalist Alain Guédé, who writes for the satirical weekly Le Canard Enchaîné, reveals an impressive and dominant figure in 18th-century Paris. The book is a novelized biography of Saint-Georges, woven through the history of a fascinating era: the decline of absolute monarchy against the backdrop of a Paris given over to revelry while the poverty of the people deepened, and the Revolution and the revolutionary upheaval that brought Napoleon to power.

Guédé places a flesh-and-blood hero within the political, economic, social and artistic contexts of the era, and introduces the reader to most of the prominent figures of the day, in whose circles Joseph moved.

Joseph was born on Christmas Day in 1739 in the colony of Guadeloupe, an island in the Caribbean. As he came out of his mother’s womb, the midwife reportedly predicted: “One day, this child will meet the king of France.” His father, Tavernier de Boulogne, was a bankrupt nobleman from the north of France who had moved to the distant island to escape his creditors, and who quickly grew rich from sugar plantations thanks to slavery. His mother, Nanon, was a beautiful slave of Senegalese origin, with whom de Boulogne fell in love.

This was the horrific era of the slave trade: the “selection” process in Africa and in the markets of the Americas, the inhumane conditions of the sea crossing, the appalling exploitation in the colonies. It was also an era when ideas of progress and liberty were flourishing, ideas that would ferment into revolution, yet slavery did not trouble the “philosophers of the Enlightenment.”

Love in Black and White

Many mixed-race children were born of the sexual exploitation of young slave women by white masters. But Tavernier was an exception: a pleasant, unassuming man who won the heart of the beautiful 18-year-old slave who had been kidnapped as a child by slave traders and brought to Guadeloupe.

He bought her for 2,000 livres and brought her into his home, to run the household and raise their son. She was so beautiful that, years later, it was written that she had been “the finest gift Africa ever gave to France.”

Map of Guadeloupe (Saint-Georges's birthplace) by Rainal. Photo source: Wikipedia
Map of Guadeloupe (Saint-Georges’s birthplace) by Rainal. Photo source: Wikipedia

Joseph received a perfect education that included music, fencing, riding, shooting, dance and academic studies. As a child, he absorbed the rhythms of the songs the slaves sang as they worked. From early childhood he stood out for his physical strength and agility, qualities that would later impress the ladies of Paris. He dressed like a nobleman’s son, but in the eyes of white society he remained “the son of a Black woman,” and was treated accordingly. He quickly became aware that the beautiful island could be paradise for some and hell for others, all because of skin color, and he lent an ear to the horror stories of what was done to the slaves.

Since the law barred Tavernier from adopting his son, from freeing him from slavery (many mixed-race children worked as slaves on the plantations), and from giving him his name, let alone the noble title he would have been entitled to had he been recognized as his son, his father did something medieval instead: he made him a chevalier, and gave him the name of the estate next to his own, Saint-Georges.

Not far from their home lived a nobleman named Davy de la Pailleterie, who had fathered four children with a beautiful slave, Cessette Dumas. He sold the mother and three of the children into slavery, and kept the fourth, Thomas Rétoré Dumas. This son bought his own freedom, rose through the ranks of the French army to the rank of general, freed his family, and later had a son, Alexandre Dumas.

Years later, the famous novelist took pains to distort history in order to glorify his father, who had been Saint-Georges’s “rival” in late-18th-century Paris, and to diminish the Chevalier’s reputation.

Le Pen Didn’t Invent Anything

Tavernier prospered, and the time came to return to France and use his wealth to buy respectability and status. In mid-18th-century France, ignorance ran deep, and racism thrived even among the “progressives.” Diderot, in the Encyclopédie, described Black people as inferior beings, almost animals.

Jean-Jacques Rousseau was no champion of theirs either, and one of his patrons did not hesitate to name his own slave ship after Rousseau’s great work, The Social Contract… Voltaire and Montesquieu were both said to have profited from the slave trade. Among noblewomen, largely under the influence of Madame de Pompadour, it became fashionable to keep Black children as decoration, as pets, and there was even a trade in Black children to supply the fad.

Plantation owners from the islands of the Caribbean used to spend a few years in France with their slaves, and even then, in Provence, people were already worried about an “invasion of Black people.” Le Pen invented nothing, even though their total number in the entire region never exceeded seventy! Fantasies about their supposed sexual potency stirred up fears.

A royal system of repression then swung into action. Until 1738, any Black person was considered freed from slavery the moment their foot touched French soil. That law was repealed. In 1763, Louis XV banned the entry of Black people into France altogether. Tradesmen such as coachmen and servants, fearing competition, saw to it that Black people were barred from practicing those trades.

Joseph was nine years old when he arrived in Paris. With the help of wealthy relatives who worked as tax collectors in the king’s service and grew rich at the people’s expense, his father began climbing from one purchased office to the next in the tax-collection business. With every step up the ladder of status and wealth, the family moved to a grander house.

He wanted to marry Nanon, whom he loved, but his relatives pressured him to marry a white noblewoman befitting his standing and to keep the mother of his son as a mistress, a solution they were willing to accept. He hesitated, but Nanon understood that she had become a burden, and gave him up. Tavernier de Boulogne married, and Joseph’s mother, the former slave, received an apartment and a generous allowance from him.

An Education in Excellence

His father devoted himself to his son’s education, determined that he would excel at every skill expected of a young nobleman: swimming, riding, fencing, dance. He insisted that Joseph master every aristocratic mannerism, so that despite his dark skin and curly hair, he would be accepted in high society.

The father had the will and the means, the boy had the talent, and the teachers were superb. His violin teacher was the kingdom’s most brilliant violinist, Leclair. Composition was taught to him by one of the greatest musicians of the age, Gossec. His father also bought him a violin made by Amati, the teacher of Stradivari. And so began the extraordinary career of a man considered one of the greatest violinists of the 18th century.

At the same time, he was admitted as a boarding student to the best fencing school in Paris, run by La Boëssière, the inventor of the fencing mask. The kingdom’s best fencers heard of the tall, powerfully built “American,” and came to challenge him. The perfect athlete proved to be the finest fencer in Paris, and also an unrivaled dancer, horseman, runner and ice skater. His even temper was praised too, but woe to anyone who mocked the color of his skin, his lips or his broad nose: he would charge and overwhelm them with his fists.

François-Joseph and Jean-Marie Leclair. Violin teachers of the Chevalier de Saint-Georges. Photo sources: Wikipedia
François-Joseph and Jean-Marie Leclair. Violin teachers of the Chevalier de Saint-Georges. Photo sources: Wikipedia

For the young Joseph, nothing mattered more than being accepted into high society. His father granted him an enormous annual allowance, which spared him the unaristocratic need to work. He took pains to turn every enemy into a friend, and to prevent the kind of hostility that quickly took on a racist tone. It did him no good.

Thanks to his skills as a fighter, he was accepted into the Musketeers, the king’s guard. But the other soldiers, sons of the kingdom’s most important noble families, shunned him, humiliated him and forced him to resign, even as noblewomen flocked to the elegantly dressed “Black Don Juan.”

Yet when he asked for the hand of one of them, her father refused him. The bitter lesson, that he would never be accepted as a Black man into a French family, stayed with him: he never again asked a woman to marry him, and his whole life became a chain of affairs with noblewomen, married and unmarried alike.

In 1769, with the founding of the first orchestra not attached to a noble household, Gossec invited Joseph to serve as first violinist and concertmaster. Despite the jealousy and the mockery of the powder he used to whiten his face, he quickly became the living spirit of the orchestra, and began composing.

But it was only in 1773 that he had his first works printed, six string quartets. The salons of the noble houses competed for his presence and his performances. Before long he was conducting the largest orchestra in the history of music up to that point, the Concert des Amateurs. He drove his 76 musicians hard, some of them noblemen who accepted his authority.

A Bombshell at Versailles

In 1774, at age 35, the 19-year-old Queen Marie Antoinette invited him to perform at Versailles. The midwife’s prophecy had come true. The queen cared little for protocol, and the “colored” man’s entry into the palace, not as a servant, rang out like a bombshell.

He quickly became the queen’s confidant, and in the evenings he would tell his mother, Nanon, about the wonders of the royal palace, its luxuries and its balls. His “friends” among the nobility courted him in order to exploit his daily meetings with the queen, who even came to Paris to hear him play and watch him skate on the frozen Seine. His bond with the queen lasted until the Revolution.

“An admired rooster surrounded by a flock of beauties, he is the shining star of the entertainments, the parties and the evening banquets,” a contemporary wrote of him. And John Adams, later the second president of the United States, noted in 1779: “He is the most accomplished man in Europe in riding, shooting, fencing, dancing and music.”

But his life was “steeped in the sorrow of loneliness,” since he could never start a family with any of the high-born women whose company he kept and enjoyed. He became a byword. In one of his novels, Balzac writes of one of his characters that he “fences like Saint-Georges.”

In 1774 he put himself forward to run the Royal Academy of Music, the Paris Opera. The queen supported him, as did the king, but the nobility objected: the royal courts of Europe would mock the appointment. The king insisted: him, or no one. A wave of racist hatred rose against the conductor, and Paris was in an uproar.

This may have been the first case of professional discrimination on racial grounds in modern society. Until then, Black people had been considered livestock, and who checks whether livestock has talent. Now the question was asked: when they are not enslaved, can Black people develop the same abilities as white people? Yes, ruled the queen. No, said the enlightened minds of the age. And they won. Racism won.

Saint-Georges, bruised but wiser for the experience, managed during the controversy to compose a symphonie concertante and five concertos. His works, which cried out with vitality against the backdrop of his constant sorrow, were among the central pieces performed by Paris’s leading orchestras. His music touches the heart, and passages of it have been called “among the most beautiful in the history of music.”

Between Mozart and Haydn

More than once, his name appeared alongside Mozart’s on concert bills. Yet in all his extensive correspondence with his father from Paris, he never once mentioned Mozart, the most prominent musician in France at the time, even as he wrote about others far less notable. Envy of a rich and successful rival?

Mozart preferred to remain poor rather than agree to have his works performed by an orchestra conducted by a man of mixed race. Not so Haydn: Saint-Georges traveled to see him and commissioned, paying full price, six symphonies, the “Paris Symphonies,” which he premiered with his own orchestra. Saint-Georges also tried his hand at writing operas. His first attempt was savaged for its weak libretto. The queen cheered, but the next day Saint-Georges pulled the show. His later works, especially The Girl Who Is a Boy, were very successful.

The “Hen” Symphony, one of the Paris Symphonies Saint-Georges commissioned from Haydn

The Revolution was drawing near, and Paris was in turmoil. During those years, Saint-Georges became friends with the Duke of Orléans, the king’s brother and the second most powerful man in the kingdom, and with his son, Philippe. Both held liberal views, were uneasy about the king’s lavish lifestyle and his obliviousness to what was happening around him, and supported far-reaching change.

The Black dandy and the duke shared an immense admiration for England, which was seen at the time as the land of liberty. The more Louis XVI voiced his hatred of England, the more the House of Orléans embraced it. The duke became a close friend of the Prince of Wales. He and Saint-Georges visited London frequently. The Black Chevalier fenced against the Prince of Wales, and let him win.

The gardens of the Palais-Royal, the palace of the House of Orléans, were by then the center of attention in Paris. In the cafés of the Palais-Royal’s covered passages, people plotted the Revolution and the abolition of slavery. Hunger drove the mob to storm the Bastille, and five weeks later, the Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen was proclaimed.

The Saint-Georges Legion

After rising to the rank of army treasurer, his father went bankrupt, and Saint-Georges was forced to rein in his extravagance. The hard years began. Even through the Revolution, he remained the foremost figure in conducting, fencing and high society.

In 1790, he starred in the last great celebration of Parisian aristocracy, just as that aristocracy was starting to flee abroad and prepare to return with the armies of foreign kings. But when a foreign army gathered and threatened to seize Paris and restore the king to his throne, 52-year-old Joseph enlisted in the National Guard, falsifying his age so he would not be turned away.

The infighting among the revolutionary factions opened his eyes to the fact that the Revolution was going off the rails, and he wrote a pamphlet: “Everything is being pushed to extremes, and the enemies of liberty are preparing to destroy the true patriots who seek to bring about a revolution with liberty at its side,” a reference to the faction of his friend, the Duke of Orléans.

He followed the debates of the National Assembly on the question of Black people with close attention. The white colonists supported the Revolution, which promised to lift trade restrictions, and in exchange they expected the new regime to help them fight the demands of Black people and people of mixed race. Their side had the upper hand.

Robespierre supported abolishing the word “slave” but not abolishing the slave trade itself. The revolutionaries also overturned the king’s decree, which had granted full rights to Black people and people of mixed race who were already free.

Despite everything, Joseph chose the Revolution as his new family. The armies of the kings crossed the borders, and Paris, where the guillotine raged and the people sang songs, was in danger. A delegation of Black people and people of mixed race presented the National Assembly with a moving manifesto in favor of racial equality, along with a proposal to form a legion of “men of color.”

In the Assembly, which had only just shaken off the abolition of slavery, emotions ran high. It appointed Saint-Georges brigade commander, the first Black colonel in the French army, at the head of the “Légion Saint-Georges.” Among the first he recruited to its ranks was the gifted swordsman Dumas, the father of…

The battle for the city of Lille (1792). Image source: Wikipedia.
The battle for the city of Lille (1792). Image source: Wikipedia.

Though he fought like a lion, saved the city of Lille and built the legion from nothing, a relentless smear campaign threatened to destroy Saint-Georges. He weathered the first wave successfully. But his enemies, and he hadn’t hesitated to quarrel with Marat, who never forgave him, stirred up a second wave of slander. He was accused of desertion from battle and tried before the revolutionary tribunal. But contrary to its usual habit of handing down the guillotine, the tribunal acquitted him.

Even that rare double stroke of luck wasn’t enough. In a third wave, he was removed from command. He appealed to the minister who had dismissed him and demanded an explanation “in the name of humanity.” A few days later he was thrown in prison, where he was held for eleven months, during which Paris’s musical life soared to new heights of popularity: 320 operas were written in five years. His musicians and friends celebrated him. Eventually people began to speak up, and they demanded his release.

The conspiracy against him was soon exposed, and he was cleared of all wrongdoing. All that was left was to demand the return of his command over the legion. But against him stood a corrupt bureaucracy, an elusive enemy he could not defeat. Robespierre was in turn sent to the guillotine, the Reign of Terror ended, and Paris returned to its carefree life. And who cared about the complaints of an aging man of mixed race who called himself a loyal revolutionary, whose father and all his relatives, tax collectors who had grown rich at the people’s expense, had long since been sent to the scaffold?

With no sources of income left, he had no choice but to work. The year was 1797. He was 58, and once again he stood at the head of an orchestra. The years and hardships had not dulled his talents. Within a short time he again became a leading figure in Paris’s festive society, and once again he was seen in the company of beautiful women many years younger than himself. A few months later he fell ill, and on June 10, 1799, he died.

Where did the Chevalier de Saint-Georges disappear to?

The story is fascinating, moving, infuriating, and the question won’t let go: why does no one know anything about him, how did the very fact of the existence of one of the most remarkable figures of the 18th century simply vanish? The answer is simple: on May 20, 1802, Napoleon Bonaparte restored slavery after crushing the slave uprising in Haiti with fire and blood.

That was the second death of the “Black Mozart,” the nickname Saint-Georges had earned in Paris in the three years after his actual death, so immense was his popularity at the time. Once again, Black people were treated as property. A decree by the ruler declared that they were incapable of any creative achievement, and that therefore the name and memory of anyone whose personal example and work proved the decree false had to be erased. Most of his works were lost from that point on. Only in recent years have a few of them been rediscovered, in archives.

Today, two hundred years later, the time has come to discover his music, to enjoy it and to work toward restoring his name in the history of the West in general and in the history of music in particular. That will happen once the world’s finest orchestras, conductors and musicians finally dare to take on the work of “the Black man of the Age of Enlightenment.”

Related reading