French kings are known for their infidelity to their lawful wives, but there was one especially daring beauty named Agnès Sorel (1422-1450), who managed to get Charles VII (r. 1422-1461), king of France, to appoint her as the first official royal mistress France had ever had. When they met, she was 20 and he was 40, married and the father of six children (the lawful queen would go on to bear him eight more), but that didn’t stop him from falling for her at first sight. In the six years they spent together, she bore him four daughters and became one of the richest and most influential women in the country.
Agnès, the official mistress, appears in several works of art, but the painting considered the most interesting, and quite bizarre, is the one that portrayed her as the Virgin Mary, pale as a corpse and baring one breast.

Royal Museum of Fine Arts, Antwerp
What’s even more surprising is that the painting was made after her death and was commissioned not by her royal lover, but by the man who served as royal treasurer, Étienne Chevalier (c. 1410-1474). Étienne and Agnès never had an affair, so to understand why he commissioned a portrait of her as the Virgin Mary, looking rather provocative, and even hung it in a very surprising place (above his wife’s tomb), you need to understand how events unfolded in the remarkable love story between the king and his official royal mistress.
Agnès Becomes a Royal Mistress
Agnès was born at a time when France was restless and at war with the English. She was the daughter of Jean Soreau and Catherine de Maignelais, who belonged to the lower nobility. Her parents gave her an excellent education: she learned to read, write, dance, sing and play several instruments. Agnès was considered a brilliant girl, a fascinating conversationalist and also very beautiful: a blonde with blue eyes.
At 15, her parents secured her a coveted position: serving as one of the ladies-in-waiting to Isabelle of Anjou, sister-in-law of Charles VII, king of France. When Agnès was about 20, the king came to visit his brother-in-law and sister-in-law, and this was the first time he saw Agnès. He was so stunned he couldn’t speak. Agnès, on the other hand, wasn’t impressed by the king: he was twenty years older than her, not a handsome man, and considered a weak, depressive and insecure king as a result of an unhappy childhood. His capricious mother had told everyone he was illegitimate, and his father, Charles VI (r. 1380-1422), was insane.

The king was captivated by Agnès, so he promoted her and gave her a new position: one of his wife’s ladies-in-waiting. He met her in secret and gave her expensive gifts: fine fabrics, jewels, furs and châteaux. Before long, Agnès became the king’s official mistress. He called her “the Lady of Beauty,” and she finally fell in love with him too. Agnès was always by his side: at the table, in bed, or in the council chamber.
The lawful queen, Marie d’Anjou (1404-1463), remained faithful to the king. She didn’t object to her husband’s new love affair and kept up a friendly relationship with Agnès. She was wise enough to understand that “marriage without love means love without marriage,” and decided to fill her time raising their 14 children.

People of the time considered Agnès the most beautiful woman in France, but no one believed Charles would stay faithful to her for more than a year or two. Agnès, however, was full of surprises. She paid close attention to her appearance and did everything she could to always look sensual and alluring: her hair was carefully styled, her dress train was much longer than those of the other women at court, and she made sure the necklines of her dresses were so deep that her breasts and nipples were clearly visible. She often went around in dresses that regularly bared one breast.

The love between Agnès and the king grew stronger by the day, and she bore him three daughters (one of them would become the mother of Louis de Brézé, husband of Diane de Poitiers, an important royal mistress in her own right). Agnès pulled the king out of his depression and pushed him to keep fighting the English enemy. She turned him into a strong, decisive and self-confident king. His forces gradually drove out the English, who had occupied a large part of France for nearly 50 years.
Until Death Do Us Part
Agnès’s recognition as the official mistress meant that together, they ruled the country; it seemed nothing in the world could stand in their way, except perhaps death. In her role, Agnès connected with the most powerful men in the kingdom: Jacques Cœur (c. 1395-1456) and Étienne Chevalier. Jacques Cœur was a wealthy merchant appointed minister of trade. Most of the people at court owed him money, and the king was his biggest debtor: Jacques personally financed the liberation of Normandy out of his own pocket. The king made sure Agnès was on good terms with him, since it was important that she know the man responsible for all the kingdom’s finances. Agnès and Jacques had a lot in common: both came from a relatively low station and had reached the highest possible rank, and almost everyone was jealous of them both, so they became very close friends.

Étienne Chevalier served as the royal treasurer. He raised the enormous sums needed to finance the long war against the English. The king asked him to fulfill all of Agnès’s wishes and whims, and the two grew very close: he became her confidant.
While Charles VII was busy fighting in Normandy, Étienne Chevalier received information about an English plot to bribe the king’s Scottish guard in order to capture him. Étienne hurried to tell Agnès the secret, and she decided she needed to warn the king herself. Even though it was winter and she was eight months pregnant, Agnès set out on a journey of hundreds of kilometers that ended with her reaching her beloved.
The two lovers only had a short time together before labor struck Agnès, but the birth did not go well. Her fourth daughter did not survive, and neither did Agnès. She was 28.
The Mysterious Portrait of Agnès Sorel
After her death, Étienne Chevalier turned to Jean Fouquet (c. 1420-1481), the official painter to him and to Charles VII, and commissioned from him a diptych (a painting made of two panels joined together with hinges), with two devotional panels to hang above his wife’s tomb.
In the left panel, we see a magnificent corridor decorated entirely with marble tiles, with two men in it. On the right, the man who commissioned the painting, the treasurer Étienne Chevalier, kneels in prayer, looking off to the side, seemingly lost in thought. His name, “Estienne,” is written in an old style on the marble column behind him in gold letters.

Beside him stands his patron saint, Saint Stephen (Étienne in French), his right hand resting on Étienne’s shoulder, his other hand resting on a New Testament, on top of which lies one of the stones used to kill him. He looks off to the side with a slightly bored expression. It made perfect sense to show a supporting saint next to a man holding a prominent and vulnerable position in the intrigue-filled royal court of Charles VII, since, as everyone knew, the king could be fickle with his favors. The saint was also meant to intercede for Étienne before the Virgin Mary, who appears in the right panel in a heavenly setting, seated on a throne carried by angels. On her lap sits the infant Jesus, pointing toward Étienne to signal that his prayer was heard and that he could hope for divine grace.
What’s surprising is that a strange atmosphere is created by the presence of the red and blue angels, and even more surprising, Mary is shown with one breast bare.

Depicting the Virgin Mary with a bare breast wasn’t new; there are plenty of other works that show her nursing Jesus as a symbol of motherhood. The main difference here is that the breast doesn’t seem to draw the child’s attention at all, which is exactly what makes Mary look a bit erotic, and of course, not by accident.
Mary is depicted in the likeness of Agnès Sorel, to glorify and elevate her. She sits on a magnificent throne, a sparkling gold crown set with precious stones on her head, presented as a queen, which is exactly how she felt in real life. Her dress has a generous neckline, revealing a perfect breast that certainly explains why the king admired her so much, and he was probably not the only one.
Why did Étienne commission her portrait? First, from today’s point of view, it’s easy to think it’s sacrilegious to portray a sinful woman, after her death, as the Virgin Mary. But in the 15th century, people believed the king was appointed by God himself, was considered holy, and granted holiness to anyone he touched. So it was fitting and proper for Agnès’s panel to feature red and blue, the colors of Christian holiness, and with the addition of white, also the colors of royalty.
Second, Agnès and Étienne had an excellent relationship. She trusted him so much that she advanced his career and named him the executor of her will, so it’s only natural that he admired the woman who influenced the king and, thanks to whom, France was liberated, and who knows, maybe he was even in love with her too.
These are good enough reasons to want to hang her portrait above his wife’s tomb; Agnès was probably more important to him, and he preferred to have her by his side always, at least on the wall. Eighteen months after Agnès’s death, rumors began that she had been poisoned, and the main suspect was the minister of trade, Jacques Cœur, who was arrested and imprisoned. That’s not surprising, considering that everyone owed him money. After about three years in prison, he managed to escape to Italy, and the charges against him were dropped.
When the painter Jean Fouquet created the painting, Jacques Cœur was sitting in prison. Étienne knew Jacques had been falsely accused, but he couldn’t openly defy the king. In the painting, Saint Stephen wears a blue robe decorated with gold stripes containing a pattern of jagged petals that, in color and shape, recall Jacques Cœur’s coat of arms, which was probably Étienne’s way of hinting at whose side he was on.

At the time, people thought Agnès died of dysentery. Modern scientists who examined her remains concluded that she died of mercury poisoning. Since mercury was sometimes used then for cosmetic preparations or to treat worms, it’s impossible to say for certain whether she was murdered. After her death, her cousin, Antoinette de Maignelais, took her place as the king’s mistress. Charles VII died 11 years later. Today, the panels hang in two different cities: Agnès’s panel in Antwerp, and Étienne’s in Berlin.
The painter, Jean Fouquet, went on to serve the next king too, Charles VII’s son, Louis XI (r. 1461-1483). The painter’s self-portrait, which was originally attached to the hinge joining the two panels, is now on display at the Louvre Museum in Paris.

Related reading